Automotive Fleet
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Advanced Safety Tech Annoys Drivers, J.D. Power Finds

A new J.D. Power survey finds car buyer demand for semi-autonomous safety technology is threatened by overbearing alerts that are causing many to disable their systems, increasing the risk of a collision.

by Staff
August 28, 2019
2 min to read


Some alerts on advanced driver assistance systems (ADAS) are so annoying or bothersome that many drivers disable the systems and may try to avoid them on future vehicle purchases, according to the J.D. Power 2019 U.S. Tech Experience Index Study.

Ad Loading...

This is a major concern for automakers keen to market these lucrative technologies and pave the way for more highly automated vehicles in the future, said Kristin Kolodge, the firm’s executive director of driver interaction and human machine interface research.

Ad Loading...

“Automakers are spending lots of money on advanced technology development, but the constant alerts can confuse and frustrate drivers,” Kolodge said. “The technology can’t come across as a nagging parent; no one wants to be constantly told they aren’t driving correctly.”

One example is lane-keeping and centering systems. On average, 23% of customers with these systems complain that the alerts are annoying or bothersome. This ranges from just 8% for one domestic brand to more than 30% for two import brands.

For these owners, 61% sometimes disable the system, compared with just 21% of those that don’t consider the alerts annoying or bothersome. Owners wanting the feature on their next vehicle ranges from 63% for those that consider the alerts annoying or bothersome to 91% for those who do not.

“Some brands are succeeding at making their safety technology effective without being overbearing. Some are good at one aspect but weaker at another, and some are struggling with both,” Kolodge said. “This is why one brand has 90% of its customers wanting lane-keeping/centering on their next vehicle, while another brand has just 59% of its customers saying the same thing.”

The study, now in its fourth year, measures owners’ experiences, usage and interaction with 38 driver-centric vehicle technologies at 90 days of ownership. Overall satisfaction with new-vehicle technology ranges widely. The best-performing vehicle in the study is the Kia Stinger, scoring 834 (on a 1,000-point scale). The overall average is 781, with the lowest-scoring model achieving just 709.

Ad Loading...

Collision protection has the highest score (813) among the six categories measured in the study. Smartphone mirroring (789) is second, followed by comfort and convenience (787), entertainment and connectivity (782), driving assistance (768), and navigation (744).

More Fleet Forward

A group of people stand next to a crashed car for IIHS testing
Fleet Forward•by Faith Howell•October 27, 2026

What Fleet Managers Learned from IIHS Crash Testing

Fleet Forward Conference attendees witnessed a live crash test at IIHS’s site, explored vehicle safety technology, and learned how IIHS research can inform fleet purchasing decisions.

Read More →
Photos on the top show attendess of the 2026 Fleet Forward Conference sitting on stage
Fleet Forward•by Staff•October 27, 2026

What Happened at Fleet Forward Conference 2026?

Here's what happened at this year's Fleet Forward conference, all in photo form.

Read More →
Chad Edmondson at Fleet Forward Conference 2026
Fleet Forward•by Jeanny Abraham•October 22, 2026

Chad Edmondson Named 2026 Fleet Safety Award Winner

The VSC Fire & Security fleet director oversees more than 1,100 assets nationwide. His approach to improving driver safety emphasizes collaboration, employee engagement, and building trust with the people behind the wheel.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Joseph Lukacs at the Fleet Forward Conferencd 2026
Fleet Forward•by Jeanny Abraham•October 22, 2026

Joseph Lukacs Wins 2026 Global Fleet Manager of the Year

The Sherwin-Williams fleet leader adds another industry honor to his career after being named the 2025 Edward J. Bobit Professional Fleet Manager of the Year.

Read More →
A blue and white graphic with Brett's Bridge's headshot on the left.
Fleet Forward•by Faith Howell•October 7, 2026

Fleet Meets: Brett Bridges

Meet Brett Bridges, project leader and industry innovator.

Read More →
Erin Gilchrist poses next a podcast mic on the left side of an image with the Mike Antich Apirit of Fleet award image on the right.
Fleet Forward•by Faith Howell•October 5, 2026

Erin Gilchrist Receives Mike Antich Spirit of Fleet Award

Last week at AFLA in Vegas, Erin Gilchrist received the inaugural, brand-new Spirit of Fleet Award.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A headshot of Dominika Leja on the right with Fleet Manager of the Year text on the left, all with a blue and red background and the Automotive Fleet logl
Fleet Forward•by Faith Howell•September 30, 2026

Dominika Leja Named the 2026 Fleet Manager of the Year

The AstraZeneca associate director of fleet was recognized for her leadership in fleet electrification, cost savings, and operational transformation.

Read More →
Jamie McKay stands on stage and poses with teh 2026 Fleet Visionary award at AFLA
Fleet Forward•by Faith Howell•September 30, 2026

Jamie McKay Named the 2026 Fleet Visionary Award Winner

The Aptive Pest Control fleet manager was recognized for her approach to operations, data, lifecycle management, and driver needs.

Read More →
FFC one day pass announce
Fleet Forward•by Staff•September 15, 2026

Fleet Forward Conference Introduces One-Day Passes for 2026

New one-day registration gives fleet professionals the flexibility to attend Tuesday, Wednesday, or Thursday, with passes available for $199 through Sept. 18.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A dog sits at a desk and vibe codes
Fleet Forward•by Chris Brown•September 1, 2026

Vibe Coding: When Fleet Managers Become Software Builders

Five fleet professionals — none with programming skills — discuss how they’re using AI to build fleet solutions in-house and in a fraction of the time.

Read More →