Automotive Fleet
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Carbon Emissions Vs. Ownership Costs: Compact SUVs

When comparing a vehicle’s carbon emissions and its total cost of ownership, which vehicles and powertrain types in the compact SUV segment offer the maximum benefit for the money? [Part 1 of 5]

February 11, 2025
Three compact SUVs in illustrative graphic.

Compact SUVs, a favorite of corporate fleets, have the most model choices and powertrains of any passenger vehicle segment, covering ICE, BEV, HEV, and PHEV. 

Photo: BBM

4 min to read


For most corporate fleet managers, balancing sustainability initiatives while keeping fleet costs in check is a top priority. Yet sourcing vehicles’ carbon emissions, matching them to vehicle routes, defining ownership costs, and then performing the cost-benefit analysis is a time and resource-consuming endeavor. 

Ad Loading...

This study may help overcome these initial hurdles. We asked the lifecycle cost experts at Vincentric to provide total cost of ownership (TCO) data for 2024 model-year vehicles driven 20,000 miles per year for five years in these categories: half-ton pickups, cargo vans, passenger cars, compact SUVs, and luxury vehicles. 

Ad Loading...

The resulting list produced close to 1,300 total vehicle configurations with gas and diesel (ICE), battery electric (BEV), hybrid electric (HEV), and plug-in hybrid electric (PHEV) powertrains.

As usual, Vincentric calculated its standard eight cost elements: depreciation, financing, fees and taxes, fuel, insurance, maintenance, opportunity cost, and repairs. This time, Vincentric also provided annual in-use carbon (CO2) emissions for each vehicle. 

We divided the analysis by segment, with Compact SUVs being the first one. But first: 

How Carbon Emissions Are Calculated

Vincentric broke out four sets of CO2 emissions by metric tons per year: 

  • Electric generated (BEVs and PHEVs): Defined by the amount of CO2 emissions produced by power plants needed to power these vehicles.

  • Tank-to-wheel (ICE & HEV): Defined by the amount of CO2 emissions produced from burning fuel within a vehicle while the vehicle is in motion.

  • Well-to-tank (ICE & HEV): CO2 emissions produced from extracting, refining, and delivering fuel to the vehicle. 

  • Annual in-use CO2 emissions: Totals the above three values for all vehicles in a single value demonstrating the yearly release of CO2 and Nitrous Oxide. 

Ad Loading...

With this data, Automotive Fleet calculated the average annual in-use CO2 emissions and TCO for every vehicle configuration, sorted by vehicle segment. We then calculated the average percentage improvement in CO2 emissions when switching from an ICE engine to a BEV, HEV, BEV, or PHEV. 

AF also included the top 5 TCO performers in each segment.

On to the analysis: 

Compact SUVs

The compact SUV segment is a favorite of corporate fleets. It certainly has the most model choices and powertrains, covering ICE, BEV, HEV, and PHEV. 

ICE: 189 configurations

  • 5-Yr TCO Average: $71,654

  • Average yearly CO2 output (metric tons): 8.68

Ad Loading...

The ICE category is the biggest by far and offers the most vehicle configurations. Eight of the top 10 spots are versions of the Subaru Crosstrek and Chevrolet Trax. 

Chart analyzing vehicle ownership costs and carbon emissions.

Eight of the top 10 spots are versions of Subaru Crosstrek and Chevrolet Trax.  

Source: BBM

BEVs: 55 configurations

  • 5-Yr TCO Average: $80,953

  • Average 5-Yr premium BEV over ICE: $9,299

  • Average yearly CO2 output (metric tons): 2.72

  • Average yearly CO2 savings by switching from ICE to BEV: 69%

As is the case in every segment, BEV configurations offer the lowest carbon output of any powerplant type. When transitioning from ICE to compact SUVs, BEVs in this segment offer a substantial 69% average reduction in carbon emissions. 

But that benefit comes at a price. Compact SUVs have an average five-year/100,000-mile TCO of $9,299 per vehicle more than the average TCO of ICE models. 

Chart analyzing vehicle ownership costs and carbon emissions.

BEV configurations offer the lowest carbon output of any powerplant type, but it comes at a cost. 

Source: BBM

PHEVs: 16 Configurations 

  • 5-Yr TCO Average: $81,205

  • Average 5-Yr premium PHEV over ICE: $9,551

  • Average yearly CO2 output (metric tons): 5.73

  • Average yearly CO2 savings by switching from ICE to BEV: 34%

Ad Loading...

Of the five segments analyzed, the compact SUV segment has PHEV variants in popular fleet models. PHEV versions of Ford Escape, Hyundai Tucson, and Jeep Wrangler took the top five TCO spots. 

These PHEVs offer an average 34% reduction in carbon emissions. However, the average TCO premium for PHEVs is more than for BEVs, with slightly less CO2 savings. 

Note that Vincentric assumes 100% battery use for all trips with its PHEVs. Real-world battery use is uneven — and often half or less than 100% — which would further erode any savings in carbon emissions and overall TCO. 

Chart analyzing vehicle ownership costs and carbon emissions.

The average TCO premium for PHEVs is more than for BEVs, with slightly less CO2 savings. 

Source: BBM

HEVs: 24 Configurations

  • 5-Yr TCO Average: $64,469

  • Average 5-Yr premium HEV over ICE: -$7,185

  • Average yearly CO2 output (metric tons): 5.63

  • Average yearly CO2 savings by switching from ICE to HEV: 35%

In this segment, versions of the Toyota RAV4 Hybrid took all five top spots. 

Ad Loading...

The hybrid models offer the best TCO of any powerplant in this analysis — and it’s not at a premium, but savings of over $7,000 on average per vehicle over five years compared to ICE models. This is combined with a 35% carbon reduction, surprisingly better than PHEVs. 

While BEVs offer almost double the carbon savings, the strong TCO offered by hybrids provides an incremental yet meaningful path toward sustainability targets while conserving the fleet budget. 

Chart analyzing vehicle ownership costs and carbon emissions.

In this segment, hybrids offer savings of over $7,000 on average per vehicle compared to ICE models. 

Source: BBM

Notes & Cautions

This analysis is meant to be directional only. It does not account for nuances in the capacities and capabilities of individual models within a segment.

The overall list includes manufacturers that don’t have a formal fleet program. They were included in the averages but not in our top 5 lists.

Often, one model dominates the top 5 TCO list. We point these cases out in the text. For the list, we include the top model’s best TCO configuration and move on to the next best-performing model. 

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Vehicle Research

Promotional graphic introducing the 2027 Fleet Fact Book, featuring the publication's cover alongside the Automotive Fleet logo, with a dark blue background and red accents.
Vehicle Research•by Chris Brown•November 20, 2026

Introducing the 2027 Fleet Fact Book

Automotive Fleet, Government Fleet, Work Truck, and Heavy Duty Trucking present the 2027 Fleet Fact Book, bringing together data and research from commercial, government, vocational, and heavy-duty fleets in one edition.

Automotive Fleet News Recap thumbnail featuring the headline “Can AEB Really Prevent Intersection Crashes?” in bold white and blue text against a dark navy background with a subtle aerial view of an intersection and crosswalks.
Vehicle Research•by Faith Howell•November 13, 2026

Can AEB Really Prevent Intersection Crashes? | AF News Recap

This week we covered the latest AEB test from AAA, a new scholarship opportunity, and Holman's huge leadership change.

Three Holman leader headshots sit next to each other with a blue background
Vehicle Research•by News/Media Release•November 12, 2026

Holman Announces Fleet Leadership Changes as Bob White Retires

Nick Caller will become president of Fleet, while Mark Bryan will take on the role of executive vice president and chief operating officer of Fleet, effective Jan. 1, 2027.

Ad Loading...
Three executives participate in a panel discussion at Toyota’s 2026 Fleet Executive Meeting, seated onstage beneath a screen displaying the Toyota logo and “Meet the Moment” theme.
Vehicle Research•by Wayne Parham•November 10, 2026

Toyota Fleet Briefs Fleet Leaders on Rapidly Growing Fleet Service Program, Successes of Hybrids, and Supply

During the annual Toyota Fleet Executive Meeting, fleet leaders learned about Toyota’s legacy of driving fuel efficiency with hybrids, its investments in U.S. production, the early success of Toyota Fleet Service Advantage, and much more.

Automotive Fleet graphic announcing NAFA’s new CAFM Scholarship Program, featuring a professional stamping paperwork, a dark blue background, and the Automotive Fleet and NAFA logos.
Vehicle Research•by News/Media Release•November 9, 2026

NAFA Launches CAFM Scholarship Program for Fleet Professionals

The new program will award up to four scholarships annually to help eligible fleet professionals cover the cost of Certified Automotive Fleet Manager certification.

Automotive Fleet and Work Truck graphic reading “2027 Fleet Awards,” “Your Fleet. Your Vote.” and “Three ballots. One deadline.” Categories include cars, trucks, SUVs, commercial vans, and upfit packages.
Vehicle Research•by Lauren Fletcher•November 6, 2026

Your Fleet Experience Deserves a Vote in the 2027 Fleet Awards

Cars, trucks, vans, SUVs, and upfits. Help choose the 2027 fleet award winners and unlock early-access resources for voters. Ballots close December 31.

Ad Loading...
commercial fleet sales January thru October year over year
Vehicle Research•by Chris Brown•November 5, 2026

Commercial Fleet Sales Rebound 16.9% Through October

October's stronger results lifted commercial fleet sales growth to 6.7% through the first 10 months of 2026.

Black-and-gold graphic reading “Vote Now” above Automotive Fleet’s 2027 Fleet Car, Truck, and SUV of the Year award logos. Voting closes December 31.
Vehicle Research•by Lauren Fletcher•November 2, 2026

Which Vehicles Earn Your Fleet’s Vote? Voting Opens for 2027 Fleet Vehicle of the Year

Which vehicles earn your fleet’s vote? Cast your ballot to unlock early access to our analysis of ownership costs across 55 vehicle nameplates.

An AF news recap
Vehicle Research•by Faith Howell•October 30, 2026

Crash Tests, Catalytic Converter Theft & Fleet Safety | AF News Recap

A stolen catalytic converter can cost a fleet far more than the replacement part. This week, we're exploring how to reduce theft-related risk, what fleet managers learned from live IIHS crash testing, the 2027 Jeep Compass's new safety features, and why supporting original industry reporting matters.

Ad Loading...
A red 2027 jeep compass drives on the road surrounded by foliage
Vehicle Research•by News/Media Release•October 29, 2026

2027 Jeep Compass Adds Standard Driver-Assistance Features, Starts at $31,985

The 2027 Jeep Compass adds standard adaptive cruise control across the lineup, along with additional technology and equipment options on select trims.