Fleets are adopting compensatory strategies to offset high fuel costs. These strategies include selector modification, revised vehicle specs, increased personal use charges, streamlined fleet operations, and driver behavior modification.
The cost of fuel is the No. 1 challenge facing fleet managers today.
The breathtaking increase in gasoline and diesel prices over the past
six years has given all of us a sobering reality check on how quickly
the price of fuel can cause fleet budgets to hemorrhage, especially in
the past year.
The new “fleet reality” is being defined by fuel. Ongoing high fuel
costs are prompting fleets to establish minimum mpg requirements for
vehicle inclusion on a selector list. However, the reality is that
fleet applications restrict vehicle choices. Most fleets have limited
options to change selectors and still get the right vehicle for the job.
Despite this obstacle, fleets are adopting compensatory strategies
to offset higher fuel costs. Each month, I am in contact with hundreds
of fleet managers around the country and I ask them what they are doing
to reduce their fuel spend. During the course of these communications,
I have collected 60 ways fleets are reducing their fuel spend.
Selector Modification
1. Spec Four-Cylinder Engines.
The No. 1 approach to reduce fuel spend is spec’ing four-cylinder
engines. An increasing number of companies are changing their 2009
specs to include a greater number of four-cylinder engines in their
selector mix. For instance, Illinois Tool Works has shifted to
four-cylinder engines. “We decided to change our vehicles from the
typical V-6 to smaller four-cylinder models,” said Keith Scolan,
manager global fleet for Illinois Tool Works in Glenview, Ill.
Endo Pharmaceuticals is also expanding its selector options with
various four-cylinder models. “We have been given the flexibility to
look at whatever manufacturers make sense for our selectors,” said Joe
Niszczak, fleet manager for Endo Pharmaceuticals in Chadds Ford, Penn.,
“As a result, I am focusing on high-output four-cylinder models from
Subaru, Toyota, and General Motors to potentially replace the full-size
sedans we are using.”
E.A. Sween Company switched to a four-cylinder Chrysler Sebring from
a six-cylinder. “The fuel savings are important to us, along with the
lower capital cost and higher resale expected,” said Gregg Hodgdon,
CAFM, director of fleet operations for E.A. Sween Company in Eden
Prairie, Minn.
Another company planning to expand its four-cylinder engine offering
is Regis Corp. “We are looking at four-cylinder vehicles for 2010 and
will be testing four-cylinder Fusions this fall,” said Nancy Barlage,
fleet administrator for Regis Corp. in Minneapolis.
Other examples of companies shifting more vehicles to four-cylinder
engines are Bausch & Lomb, Owens Corning, Kraft Foods, Johnson
& Johnson, Merck, Abbott, Infinity Insurance, etc.
[PAGEBREAK]
2. Establish Minimum MPG Requirement for Selector Placement.
To add a vehicle to the fleet selector, some fleets require it must
have minimum mpg rating. PPG is adopting a 30-mpg minimum for its fleet
selector. “Our sedans for the 2009 model-year lineup will all have
four-cylinder engines that get a minimum of 30 mpg,” said Charles
Szymanski, manager global property casualty insurance & auto fleet,
for PPG Industries in Pittsburgh, Penn.
Another company that bases selector decisions on EPA ratings is
Labcorp. “We choose those vehicles with the best EPA fuel economy
ratings,” said Lynda Dinwiddie, associate VP, fleet & travel for
Labcorp in Burlington, N.C.
3. “Right-sizing” to a Smaller Vehicle.
“We are attempting to downsize our fleet where it makes sense,” said
Craig Howard, fleet manager for Verizon Business Fleet Operations.
Likewise, Toshiba America Medical Systems is investigating the
feasibility of downsizing to smaller vehicles. “I am working with our
service executive team to determine if we can possibly downsize from
the Grand Caravan to a smaller more fuel-efficient vehicle,” said Jeff
Berg, manager fleet & travel administration for Toshiba America
Medical Systems in Tustin, Calif.
Honeywell has been “right-sizing” its cargo-type vehicles for the
past few years. “We are continuing to right-size cargo-type vehicles by
offering the Chevy HHR with a ladder rack for those that have a
mini-cargo van, just to carry a ladder,” say Shelly Lofgren, fleet
manager for Honeywell International.
4. Expand Hybrid Fleet.
More fleets are looking to add hybrids to their selectors,
especially for urban applications. “We are looking to increase use of
hybrids for inner-city vehicles and alternative fuels such as CNG,”
said Howard of Verizon.
USG is also expanding its fleet of hybrids. “Toyota Prius remained
on the selector for the second year with the addition of the Camry
Hybrid at the sales manager level,” said Maria Williams, fleet
operations supervisor for USG Corp. Another company increasing its
investment in hybrid vehicles is Toshiba America Medical Systems. “We
are in the process of converting our 150 Chrysler 300s over to Toyota
Camry Hybrids,” said Berg of Toshiba America Medical Systems. “So far,
we have replaced about 70 vehicles and should have the rest replaced in
the next 18-24 months.”
Examples of other corporate fleets that have made substantial
investments in hybrid vehicles are Hoffmann-LaRoche, Johnson &
Johnson, PepsiCo, Consolidated Coca-Cola Bottling, Apple Inc., etc.
5. Tighten 4x4 Eligibility.
Another trend is to eliminate across-the-board 4x4 use. “We are
making recommendations to management to go back to only offering
four-wheel-drive vehicles for Snow Belt territories, taking larger SUVs
and minivans off the selectors for sales groups that don’t really need
them to do their jobs,” said Donna Bibbo, manager, fleet & employee
services for Novo Nordisk Inc. in Princeton, N.J.
At a growing number of fleets, a driver must obtain management
approval to get a 4x4 vehicle. “If a driver says 4WD is necessary, it
is now the exception rather than a standard,” said Debbie Lakes,
manager – corporate fleet for Flowserve Corp. in Dayton, Ohio.
Personal Use Charges Raised
6. Increase Personal Use Charges.
There is a broad-based trend to increase personal use charges to drivers.
Many fleets are re-examining chargeback systems to determine whether
personal use expenses are adequately recouped. Many fleets have
increased personal use charges in reaction to higher fuel prices. The
average personal use charge to employees in 2005 was $70-$90 per month.
Today, it ranges from $80-$150 per month, with an average of $105 per
month. The question is whether it needs to go even higher in today’s
cost environment. Personal use of company vehicles accounts for
approximately 15-18 percent of the overall miles accumulated during a
vehicle’s service life.
7. Eliminate Personal Use.
Some companies are considering the outright elimination of personal use privileges to reduce fuel spend.
[PAGEBREAK]
8. Monitoring Unauthorized Company Vehicle Usage.
In the era of lower fuel prices, companies often missed or ignored
unauthorized use of company vehicles such as when an employee took a
vacation. “I am running a monthly vacation report and will be checking
it against fuel purchase dates as our employees are not allowed to use
their fuel card for extended personal trips or vacations,” said one
fleet manager who wished to remain anonymous.
Modifying Fleet Operations
9. Implement Idle Reduction Programs.
The worst mileage a vehicle can get is 0 miles per gallon, which
occurs when it idles. Idling for long periods of time, whether at a
railroad crossing or pulling off the road to make a cell phone call,
consumes gas that could be saved by simply turning off the engine.
Restarting an engine uses about the same amount of gas as idling for 30
seconds. When idling for longer periods of time, shut off the engine.
Prolonged idling creates excess emissions and wastes fuel. However,
as a caution, turning off the engine may disable safety features such
as airbags. Drivers should be certain to utilize this strategy only in
situations where there is no possibility of collision.
“We have communicated reminders to all our employees about our
no-idle policy,” said Hodgdon of E.A. Sween Company. “On our Class 8
trucks, we are ordering Thermo King APU equipment to eliminate the need
to idle to power A/C, heat, etc.”
10. Develop a More Efficient Routing Plan.
If you are running a delivery fleet or have vehicles that follow a
set daily pattern, efficient routing offers an effective way for fleets
to manage fuel expenses. Not only does a routing plan make trips more
fuel-efficient, but it also increases time efficiency as well. Plan and
consolidate trips to bypass congested routes and avoid stop-and-go
traffic.
Fleets are also reducing fuel spend by optimizing trip routing to
avoid unnecessary travel and backtracking. “We are looking at ways to
redesign our distribution system that will be more efficient,” said
Hodgdon.
Other companies are evaluating routing software to optimize routing.
“We are investigating a routing software package that would help us
optimize our delivery routes to minimize miles driven,” said Jim
Collins, CAFM, manager, support services for Royal Cup, Inc. in
Birmingham, Ala.
Other fleets require strict adherence to routing plans. “We require
strict adherence to the routing plan produced by our dynamic routing
programs that minimize mileage, while maximizing customer service” said
Steven LaPorte, business manager, North American transportation
operations for Iron Mountain in Boston, Mass.
11. When Feasible, Have Two Employees per Vehicle.
If you have several employees going to the same work location or job
site, have them take one vehicle instead of driving separately.
12. Optimizing Fleet Utilization and Realigning Vehicle Assignments.
Fleets are closely examining vehicle mileage records and eliminating
marginal low-mileage vehicles that do not fully contribute to
fulfilling the fleet application.
“We work under the premise that there are two ways to lower fleet
costs: dispose of every vehicle you don’t need and modification of
driver behavior,” said Ginny Liddle, corporate fleet administrator for
Terracon in Olathe, Kan. “I provide a quarterly exception report to
management listing the vehicles that have been driven less than 1,500
miles. With this and feedback from their own managers, they can make an
informed decision whether to keep, dispose or transfer a vehicle.
Modifying driver behavior is an ongoing process.”
Another strategy employed by some truck fleets is to realign truck
assignments to be closer to the dealer repair network to minimize fuel
expenditures in traveling to and fro. For instance, E.A. Sween Company
is in the process of realigning its 250 Deli Express truck assignments.
“We see the overall best repairs with fewer re-visits using a truck
dealer repair network. Currently, the nearest dealer repair facility
could be over a hundred miles away while we are parked at night near
another brand of truck dealer. The fuel used for transportation to
repair locations along with employee time to move a truck represents an
opportunity for improvement,” said Hodgdon. “The extra transportation
and repair time increases our need for spare trucks. Realignment will
place more trucks with service locations that can provide quick and
proper repairs allowing us to eliminate about 20 percent of our spare
trucks.”
13. Eliminating Pool Vehicles.
“We are taking a close look at all our pool vehicles to see if we
can eliminate some underutilized vehicles,” said Brett Switzky, fleet
services administrator for American Family Mutual Insurance Co. in
Madison, Wis.
[PAGEBREAK]
Truck Fuel Management
14. Minimize Truck Overloading.
Not only does overloading consume additional fuel, it poses a safety
risk and unnecessary wear and tear on the vehicle. “In our business,
our trucks are either fully loaded to the GVWR or on the road
constantly or both. It is a challenge to lower our fuel costs based on
our business requirements and the type of vehicle we need to do the
job,” said Brenda Davis, fleet manager for Baker Hughes in Houston.
15. Modifying Truck Specs.
One way to reduce fuel expenditures is by modifying truck specs to
increase mpg fuel economy. For example, fleets in certain industries
are making changes to their truck, upfit, and tractor specifications to
help improve fuel economy.
16. Modify Tire Specifications.
One cost reduction strategy is altering tire specifications, such as switching to low rolling resistance tires.
“We are examining the ROI on low rolling resistance (LRR) tires,”
said J.J. Keig, CAFM, director of fleet maintenance for Brinks in
Dallas, Texas. “The unfortunate issue is that often the tires are
priced at a premium cost, which can eliminate or even offset the fuel
savings on a cost basis.”
17. Over-Spec’ing Truck Engines.
PHH Arval recently conducted a study that showed fuel costs can be
reduced by slightly over-spec’ing a truck. Fuel economy was improved by
as much as 0.3 mpg by slightly over-spec’ing an engine to run more
consistently in the “sweet spot,” choosing a gear ratio low enough to
suit a fleet’s application and location and enabling the correct
fuel-efficient, engine-specific parameters.
[PAGEBREAK]
18. Optimizing Drivetrain Configurations.
By gearing a truck so the engine is running at a slower RPM at a
given speed, less fuel is burned. This must be balanced with meeting
“startability and gradeability” requirements.
“We are optimizing drivetrains by careful spec’ing of vehicles,
engines, transmission, and drive axles, which include synthetic
lubricants in all drivetrain components and axle hubs” said Keig.
19. Multi-torque or Multi-Horsepower Engines.
These engines run at a lower rating when the driver is operating the
throttle. When the cruise control is engaged, the engine rating is
increased to its higher rating. This encourages a driver to use cruise
control, which can save fuel over a driver-controlled throttle.
20. Spec Auto Shift on Tractor Trucks.
“We have always used automatics in our trucks and vans, but last
year began spec’ing the auto shifts for the tractors,” said LaPorte of
Iron Mountain.
21. Change Axle Ratios for Trucks.
“We changed axle ratios on our trucks to take advantage of lower top
speeds, while ensuring we will have the ability to leverage the 55 mph
national limit, which may happen,” said Hodgdon.
22. Make Your Vehicle More Aerodynamic.
Wind drag is a key source of reduced fuel mileage, causing an engine
to work harder, thereby reducing fuel economy. The faster you push a
vehicle, the more air it must push out of the way. Even with all the
talk about the aerodynamics of today’s vehicles, some trucks, vans, and
SUVs have the aerodynamics of a brick.
Another way to minimize wind drag is to keep the windows rolled up.
This allows air to flow over the body, rather than drawing it inside
the cabin and slowing down the vehicle. Wide-open windows, especially
at highway speeds, increase aerodynamic drag, and the result is up to a
10-percent decrease in fuel economy. If you want fresh air, run the
climate system on “outside air” and “vent,” and crack the window for
additional ventilation.
If you drive a pickup, lowering the tailgate creates turbulence,
which makes for more wind drag, and that makes the truck less
fuel-efficient at high-way speeds. By leaving the tailgate up, a smooth
bubble of air in the bed is created. Air coming over the truck cab
passes over it, thus improving fuel efficiency.
Other truck specifications to decrease fuel expenditures include
specifying aerodynamic mirrors, moving air filters under the hood, and
dropping fender-mounted mirrors.
23. Reduce Height of Cargo Boxes.
“We cut one foot off our roof box height several years ago to reduce
drag. We didn’t need the space,” said LaPorte of Iron Mountain.
24. Remove Bug Deflector Shields.
More and more fleets are removing extraneous devices from vehicle
exteriors, in particular trucks. “I am in the process of removing all
bug deflector from our trucks,” said Theresa Anderson, corporate
equipment manager for Parsons in Sumner, Wash. “It is a proven fact
that this saves fuel.”
25. In-Cab Monitoring of Fuel Economy.
Some fleets are installing in-cab electronics for drivers to monitor fuel economy performance while driving.
[PAGEBREAK]
Modification of Driver Behavior
26. Changing Driving Habits.
An easy way to reduce fuel spend is to change drivers’ habits that
unnecessarily consume fuel. “We have a driver awareness campaign to
make them aware of how much excessive idling, aggressive driving
behavior, improper tire pressure, etc., affect mpg and our carbon
footprint,” said Howard of Verizon.
A similar approach has been adopted by Baker Hughes. “We are
communicating to our drivers about the importance of maintenance,
repairs, idling, tire inflation, etc.,” said Davis.
Changing driver attitude is easier said then done. “One challenge we
face is changing our drivers’ driving habits,” said Scolan of Illinois
Tool Works. “During this time of higher fuel cost, slower driving, more
efficient routes, and less idling time will hopefully reduce costs.”
Fleet managers use e-mail newsletters to communicate these tips to
drivers. “I put articles in our electronic newsletters to make the
drivers more aware of how their actions can increase or decrease fleet
costs,” said Liddle of Terracon. Similarly, other companies have
developed a DVD on fuel economy tips to distribute to drivers.
Oftentimes, small increases in mpg can result in substantial savings
when extrapolated across the entire fleet. “Recently, we calculated the
annual savings in fuel cost we could gain if each of our drivers simply
increased their individual fuel economy by one mile per gallon,” said
Dinwiddie of Labcorp. “To facilitate this process, we’ve sent out
various fuel savings tips. At the end of the year, we’ll compare our
overall mpg for year-end 2008 versus year-end 2007. A
one-mile-per-gallon fuel efficiency increase has the potential of
saving us over $1 million annually versus 2007.”
PPG is also implementing a driver communication program. “We are
conducting a rigorous communication campaign to outline how driver
behavior can be a major influence in our fuel usage,” said Szymanski of
PPG. “We have provided hard copy letters, e-mails, and Web links, which
describe many of the ways drivers can save fuel. Our internal fleet Web
site also provides this information as well as a Web-based locator for
www.cheapgas.com.”
27. Have Drivers Ensure Tires are Inflated to the Correct Pressure.
This is the cheapest and easiest way to control fuel expenses and
the one most often overlooked. It is worth the expense to buy tire
gauges for drivers so they can ensure that tires are inflated to the
manufacturer’s recommended level. One underinflated tire can cut fuel
economy by 2 percent per pound of pressure below the proper inflation
level. One out of four drivers, on average, drive vehicles with one or
more underinflated tires. When a tire is underinflated, by 4 to 5 psi
below the manufacturer’s recommended tire pressure, vehicle fuel
consumption increases by 10 percent and, over time, causes a 15-percent
reduction in tire tread life. Check the vehicle’s doorpost sticker for
minimum cold tire inflation pressure.
28. Make Drivers Energy Conscious.
Similar to turning off the lights in unoccupied rooms at home,
drivers should practice energy conservation habits in their vehicles as
well. If a vehicle has a trip computer, encourage drivers to use the
“instant fuel economy” display to refine driving habits.
Similarly, fleets are encouraging drivers to be “price sensitive”
when refueling. “We encourage drivers and managers to look for the best
net fuel pricing,” said LaPorte of Iron Mountain.
29. Institute Driver Training Course on How to Improve Fuel Economy.
Some fleets are evaluating the use of online training modules that teaches fuel conservation techniques for drivers.
30. Communicate Fuel Saving Tips to Drivers.
“I send fuel saving tips to all of our drivers,” said Berg of
Toshiba America Medical Systems. Another company increasing
communications to drivers is E.A. Sween Company. “We communicate to all
of our employees the methods to conserve fuel with lower highway speeds
and driver behavior changes,” said Hodgdon.
31. Incorporate Fuel Economy Suggestions in E-mail Communications.
At the bottom of every e-mail from Lofgren of Honeywell are six
suggestion on how to reduce fuel spend. These include maintaining
proper tire inflation, changing driving habits, such as not racing to a
red light, maintaining posted highway speeds, and eliminating
unnecessary idling engines.
32. Clean Out the Trunk and Eliminate Unnecessary Weight.
Cars, like cargo trucks, get much better mileage when they’re not
loaded with unnecessary weight. According to AutoZone, every 200 lbs.
of additional weight trims one mile off fuel efficiency. Most drivers
accumulate material in their trunks, much of it unnecessary. Instruct
drivers to remove all unnecessary items from the trunk, such as
unneeded tools or materials.
33. Encourage Carpooling When Appropriate.
Encourage drivers to carpool when they know that they will be in the office all day for meetings or catching up with paperwork.
34. Drive the Posted Speed Limit.
Driving fast wastes gas. Traveling at 65 miles per hour uses 10-15
percent more fuel than driving at 55 mph. By adhering to speed limits,
a driver will conserve fuel.
“We have limited our top speed to 68 mpg,” said Hodgdon. “We are
unable to lower it further because it would increase our workday –
making them too long.”
35. Use Cruise Control during Highway Driving.
Unnecessary changes in speed are wasteful, and the use of cruise control helps improve fuel economy.
[PAGEBREAK]
36. Avoid Jackrabbit Starts.
A car consumes extra fuel when accelerating. To maximize fuel
economy, drivers need to examine their driving habits. Simply limiting
acceleration and fast braking can increase fuel economy. When
accelerating, suggest drivers pretend they have a fresh egg underneath
their right foot. A light, steady pressure helps to minimize the amount
of fuel consumed and maintain a more moderate and steady speed.
37. Anticipate Traffic Flow.
Anticipate traffic conditions, and accelerate and decelerate
smoothly — it’s safer, uses less gas, and reduces brake wear. In
commuter traffic, which usually involves stop-and-go movement, drivers
should look two or more vehicles ahead rather than watching the driver
directly in front of them. This enables more gradual acceleration and
deceleration. By anticipating a traffic light change, an upcoming stop
sign, or the need to slow down for a curve, drivers can avoid or reduce
brake use and save gasoline in the process.
Like the “jack-rabbit start,” the “jackrabbit stop” is a major
contributor to inefficient driving. When coming upon a “merge ahead”
sign, drivers should automatically check their speed, traffic spacing,
and length of the acceleration lane to merge smoothly without
interrupting momentum any more than necessary.
38. Avoid Aggressive Driving.
The largest fuel waste occurs with aggressive driving. Time studies
show that fast starts, weaving in and out of traffic, accelerating to
and from a stop light doesn’t save much time, wastes fuel and wears out
components such as brakes and tires faster. By not driving
aggressively, drivers can save up to 20 percent in fuel economy,
advises the EPA.
39. Use A/C Sparingly.
Use the air conditioner only when needed. An air conditioner is one
of the biggest drains on engine power and fuel economy. It can reduce
gas consumption by 5 to 20 percent, depending on the type of vehicle
and the way it is driven. Don’t use it as a fan to simply circulate
air. If it’s just too hot to bear without A/C, try to keep it set at
around 72 degrees. Minimize use of air conditioning. Use the vent
setting as much as possible.
Fleet Management Strategies
40. Develop a Written Fuel Policy for Drivers to Adhere.
What are your fuel management policies? Are those policies
understood by both drivers and management? Too often, fleets have no
written fuel management policy in place. This policy would serve as a
blueprint to reduce fuel spend and as an enforcement tool to ensure
compliance with internal fueling policies.
41. Increase Overall Average Fleet MPG.
Companies such as Johnson & Johnson have established goals to
increase the overall fleet average. In the case of Johnson &
Johnson, the goal is to increase the overall average fleet mpg to 36.4
mpg by 2010.
42. Get a Fleet Fuel Card.
A fuel management program helps avoid unauthorized purchases by
allowing fleet managers to control exactly what drivers’ purchase.
Limiting the type of fuel purchased is an easy way to control costs. A
fuel card can restrict driver purchases to only regular unleaded
gasoline, not more expensive premium and super-unleaded grades of
gasoline.
43. Eliminate SUVs, Shift to Crossovers, When Possible.
“We are reducing the number of mid-size SUVs in our fleet,” said
Mary Pat Crabtree, relocation/fleet specialist for Brown-Forman. “Along
with increasing the number of sedans, we will add crossover vehicles,
such as the Edge, Equinox, Outlook, and Journey for those jobs that
require a larger vehicle.”
44. Shift from Minivans to Sedans, When Possible.
“We previously purchased 60-percent minivans and 40-percent sedans
in our sales and technical fleet,” said Szymanski of PPG Industries.
“For this order cycle, we implemented gatekeepers at the VP level to
review and approve an individual’s requirement of a minivan. We expect
our minivans will drop to approximately 15 percent,” said Szymanski.
[PAGEBREAK]
45. Eliminate Pickups When Possible.
Some companies are eliminating trucks and shifting to crossovers, if
able to fulfill the fleet application. One company shifting away from
pickups is Advanced Stores Co. Inc.
“In the past, our fleet consisted of 100-percent light-duty pickup
trucks,” said Carol Davies, CAFM, fleet manager, store support center
for Advance Stores Co. Inc. in Roanoke, Va. “In 2008, we moved to the
Pontiac Vibe for an increase in fuel economy. We have built the fleet
up to 13 percent of our fleet and expect to grow that number in 2009.
We have increased our fuel mpg by 9 gallons per mile.”
Another example is Flowserve Corp. “We are working with our drivers
to reduce the number of F-150 Super Crews unless a truck is truly
needed for the job,” said Lakes. “In the past, it was just one of our
four choices that anyone could order. Our new process has helped us
save money by only using trucks where essential.”
Another company decreasing the number of pickups in its fleet is
USG. “We have eliminated the number of pickup trucks and are extending
their replacement mileage,” said Williams of USG.
46. Tighten Driver Eligibility.
The rule of thumb is that an employee must drive a minimum 12,000
business miles a year to be eligible for a company-provided vehicle.
Some companies are increasing this to a minimum of 15,000 business
miles to eliminate marginal drivers and to reassign responsibilities to
other drivers.
Sprint Nextel has eliminated nonessential drivers to reduce fuel
spend. “We took over 500 nonessential vehicles out of the fleet,” said
Bret Watson, CAFM, national fleet manager for Sprint Nextel Corp.
Fuel Management
47. Police Exception Reports.
Fleet managers are paying increased attention to exception reporting
provided by their fuel management providers. Identify drivers who
purchase more gallons of fuel than the capacity of their fuel tank at a
single refueling. This may indicate that a driver is fueling another
vehicle or storing fuel in gasoline canisters for personal use. Also,
monitor multiple refueling during the weekend and too-frequent
refueling that doesn’t correspond to a vehicle’s mpg.
“We are keeping a close eye on exception reporting, such as the use
of premium fuel, fuel purchases exceeding fuel tank capacity, etc., and
raising awareness of drivers’ need to perform regular PMs, keep tire
pressure monitored, and reduce cargo load,” said Barlage of Regis Corp.
Another fleet aggressively enforcing exception reports is Toshiba
America Medical Systems. “I receive a premium fuel purchase report from
our fleet management company, and I send an e-mail to those employees
reminding them of our policy to not purchase premium fuel. For those
who do not listen, I escalate it to their managers,” said Berg of
Toshiba America Medical Systems.
Agreeing is Hodgdon of E.A. Sween Company. “We have tightened up our
fuel usage monitoring program,” said Hodgdon. Likewise, H.J. Heinz Co.
in Pittsburgh, Penn., has adopted a more in-depth “watchdog” approach
to fuel expenses, said Fleet Manager Paula Bucklad. “We are working
with those with company vehicles as opposed to working against them. We
are alerting them to ways of conserving fuel, as well as the grade of
fuel to purchase,” said Bucklad. “If you are straight-forwarded with
the employees as to ‘what the flip side of the coin could be if the
costs continue to escalate,’ they tend to work with you.”
48. Investigate Fuel Hedging.
“We will likely investigate fuel hedging for CY2009. Hedging doesn’t
necessarily save you money, but it can smooth your expenses and avoid
price spikes,” said LaPorte of Iron Mountain.
49. Use Tier 2 & 3 Fuel Suppliers.
“We began an initiative last year to increase fuel purchasing volume
with Tier 2 and Tier 3 suppliers, who typically charge less. Already,
we have increased our volume by 15 percent,” said Michael Bieger,
senior director – shared services for Automatic Data Processing.
50. Don’t Buy Premium Fuel.
Use a high-quality fuel with the lowest appropriate octane rating.
Check the owner’s manual for the manufacturer’s recommendation.
There is no benefit to using premium gas in a vehicle calibrated for
regular unleaded. Resist the urge to buy higher-octane gas for
“premium” performance, unless the vehicle requires it. Octane has
nothing to do with gasoline performance. “Octane is a resistance to
knock and does not influence the volatility factor of fuel,” said Keig.
“Many people associate premium fuel to be better for an engine, which
is simply not true.” Unless the vehicle’s owner’s manual specifically
requires it, don’t use premium fuel. Most fleet vehicles are designed
to run on unleaded regular and filling up with premium only increases
cost, not performance.
Fuel costs could go down as much as 10 cents per gallon by buying regular fuel instead of premium.
51. Buy Fuel in the Morning.
To maximize fuel economy, Kelley Blue Book suggests buying gasoline
when the temperature is cold and gasoline is at its densest. Consumers
are charged based on volume, not density. Buy gasoline during the
coolest time of the day or first thing in the morning. Conversely, heat
causes fuel to expand and overflow. Don’t completely fill the gas tank
in hot weather.
52. Maintain Constant Awareness of Market Prices for Fuel.
“Our managers are tied into every local fuel location in their
geography and they check prices everyday. We move from one fuel stop to
another to save a nickel a gallon,” said Paul Gossard, corporate
director of safety, risk management, and quality assurance for
Permasteelisa in Miami, Fla.
[PAGEBREAK]
Vehicle Maintenance
53. Ensure Vehicles are in Peak Operating Condition.
“We have an active program to ensure vehicles are in peak operating
condition from a maintenance and filter perspective,” said Keig of
Brinks.
54. Monitor Preventive Maintenance Schedules.
Proper maintenance increases a vehicle’s fuel economy. For example,
keep the wheels aligned. Wheels that “fight” each other waste fuel.
Keep the air filter clean. “A dirty air filter can diminish the ability
of the engine to realize optimum fuel/air ratios, thereby reducing the
available power and operating efficiency,” said Keig of Brinks.
“Filters should be inspected carefully and more often in hostile
environments.” Replace the air filter as recommended — always consult
the owner’s manual. Use good quality, energy conserving (EC) oils that
have a viscosity grade consistent with the manual. Look for bottles
marked with the symbol ECII, the American Society of Testing Materials
logo for fuel-efficient oils. This will ensure the vehicle’s engine
will operate at maximum efficiency, thus providing the best fuel
economy.
55. Use Fuel with Detergent Additive.
Use a fuel with good detergent additives to keep the vehicle engine
clean and performing efficiently. “These additives keep critical engine
components clean and do not allow harmful deposits to enter the fuel
and intake areas, which may diminish power and efficiency,” said Keig.
Telematics Approach
56. Implement Telematic Devices to Reduce Fuel Spend.
Some fleets are adopting a technology-based solution to reduce fuel
spend. “We are looking to increase our telematic program, which is
pending review,” said Howard of Verizon.
Honeywell also hopes to move forward on a telematics program to
enhance fuel efficiency. “We conducted a pilot telematics program in
our cargo-type vehicles,” said Lofgren. “The recommendation is being
made to move forward and it is now under review by management.”
Other fleets are attempting to minimize idling. Recent telematic
data acquired reveals that fleets tremendously underestimate the amount
of idling that occurs.
57. Implement GPS Tracking Systems.
These systems have a dual purpose of tracking unauthorized travel
and for route optimization. “We have started using GPS on some of our
vehicles, and with proper controls and monitoring, we have reduced
excess idle time and speeding in some of our branches,” said Kirk
Herniman, manage, equipment & leasing for IES in Houston.
Other fleets are also adopting GPS systems to reduce fuel
expenditures. ValleyCrest Companies in Calabasas, Calif., reports a
10-percent reduction in fuel costs since implementing a fleet-wide GPS
system.
Miscellaneous Stratagems
58. Develop an In-House Team to Reduce Fuel Costs.
According to Charles Bowen, director of fleet for Rollins Inc. in
Atlanta, “We created a small team, utilizing internal resources that is
looking more closely at fuel transactions and finding excess vehicles
for turn-in.”
59. Benchmark Fuel Reduction Program.
Fleets are beginning to gauge the effectiveness of their fuel
reduction programs by benchmarking against fleets to determine best
practices.
60. Increasing MPG for Reimbursed Drivers.
Even if a company does not offer a company-provided vehicle, it is still
paying
for the business-related fuel expenditures for employee-owned vehicles.
“I am in the process of modifying our fleet policy to require that our
reimbursed drivers obtain a minimum 20 mpg on their new personal
vehicles,” said Berg of Toshiba America Medical Systems