Automotive Fleet
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Michigan Ranks Highest in Car Insurance Rates

Michigan is the most expensive state for car insurance, while Maine, Ohio and Idaho with their large swatches of rural areas are the least expensive, according to Insure.com.

by Staff
August 2, 2017
Michigan Ranks Highest in Car Insurance Rates

Photo via Wikipedia.

2 min to read


Photo via Wikipedia.

Michigan is the most expensive state for car insurance, while Maine, Ohio and Idaho with their large swatches of rural areas are the least expensive, according to Insure.com.

Ad Loading...

The average annual premium in Michigan has reached $2,394, and the state has been at the top of this list for four consecutive years. The premium is 82% higher than the national average of $1,076.

Ad Loading...

"Michigan residents can blame their unique no-fault system for their high cost of auto insurance," said Penny Gusner, consumer analyst for Insure.com. "It allows for unlimited medical benefits for injuries sustained in auto accidents and a lot of fraud arises — the result is exorbitant car insurance premiums for car owners."

Other highest-cost insurance states include Louisiana ($1,921), Connecticut ($1,897), Rhode Island ($1,848), and Florida ($1,840).

Louisiana’s high rates are due in large part to the litigious culture of the state, according to Insure.com. When large claims are continually paid out, insurance companies raise all policyholders’ premiums to cover these settlements.

At the other end of the spectrum, the average annual premium in Maine has reached $864. That state has offered the cheapest insurance for three consecutive years. The Michigan rate is 177% higher than the Maine average.

While insuring a 2017 Toyota Camry LE in Michigan would cost $2,711 on average, that same car would draw an average rate of $845 in Maine.

Ad Loading...

Other lower cost states include Ohio ($919), Idaho ($942), Vermont ($948), and North Carolina ($1,010).

Car insurance requirements vary by state, and that’s one reason for the differences in rates, according to the survey. Other reasons include state legal systems, how the state is affected by natural disasters, crime rates and the frequency and severity of claims.

More Operations

AF news recap thumbnail
Operations•by Faith Howell•October 26, 2026

Personal-Use Charges Rise as Vehicle Values Fall | AF News Recap

Personal-use charges are climbing, wholesale used-vehicle values are declining, and commercial fleet sales growth is slowing. This week, we're breaking down the latest fleet data, plus how Element Fleet Management is helping Waymo prepare for its first Canadian robotaxi market.

Read More →
A transparent blue background of a hand stamping a paper is the background of text that says "What about fleet policy exceptions?" with the Automotive Fleet logo in the bottom right corner.
Operations•by Faith Howell•October 20, 2026

Here's When You Should Make an Exception to Fleet Policy

Fleet policies are designed to create consistency, but not every driver or situation fits neatly within standard rules.

Read More →
A hand writing on an ipad with a transparent AI graphic over it
Operations•October 20, 2026

AI-Native or AI-Acquired: What Should Fleet Managers Look for in an AI Platform?

Six questions can help fleet managers look beyond AI marketing claims to evaluate integration, data access, and real-world operational performance.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Chevin 2026 Buyes Guide cover
Sponsored•October 14, 2026

A buyer's guide to fleet management software in 2027

Buying fleet management software in 2027 means looking beyond features and price. As fleet operations, technology and expectations evolve, this guide explores what today’s fleet professionals should consider when choosing a system that can deliver value now and adapt to what comes next.

Read More →
An overhead image of a freeway system with no vehicles
Sponsored•by Shelley Mika•October 13, 2026

What Will Shape the Next Era of Fleet Management?

EVs, AI, and autonomous vehicles are reshaping fleet management. Discover what’s ahead—and how fleet leaders can prepare for the next era.

Read More →
A Cox Fleet technician working on the left with the rear view of a military man saluting a flag on the right
Operations•October 8, 2026

How Fleets Can Recruit and Train Veterans for Technician Roles

Here's how the technician shortage has affected uptime for fleets, and what to do about it.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A transparent toll background with the Automotive Fleet logo and Neology logo on top.
Operations•October 5, 2026

Avis Budget Group Deploys Neology Toll Management Technology Across Major Brands

Neology’s neoFleet platform will manage toll transactions and toll-authority operations for vehicles across Avis, Budget, Payless, Budget Truck and Zipcar.

Read More →
wedding album, car, and car keys
Operations•by Chris Brown•October 2, 2026

Fleet Personal-Use Charges Edge Higher in 2026

Nearly eight in 10 surveyed fleets allow personal use of company vehicles, while just over half of respondents report charging employees for the privilege.

Read More →
AF news recap thumbnail
Operations•by Faith Howell•October 2, 2026

The Future of Fleet + What’s Changing Right Now | AF News Recap

Could developments overseas offer a preview of what’s coming for U.S. fleets? This week, we’re looking at the future of AI, autonomy, and electrification, plus Ford Pro’s new certified pre-owned program, smarter vehicle offboarding, and a new way for fleets to manage toll expenses.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
blue text over top of the top view of cars in a parking lot
Operations•by Faith Howell•October 1, 2026

How to Handle Vehicle Offboarding

What do fleet managers need to do when a driver leaves?

Read More →