Automotive Fleet
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Tests of Plug-In Hybrids Register Mixed Results

Plug-in hybrid Toyota Prius tests by city of Seattle and Idaho National Laboratory show an average of only 51 mpg.

by Staff
May 7, 2009
2 min to read


Although city officials in Seattle say they are happy with the more than a dozen Toyota Prius hybrids in its fleet with new plug-in technology, the vehicles are coming nowhere near the claims that they would get 100 mpg using battery packs installed in the trunk, according to Wired.com. The test hybrids have been equipped with the Hymotion aftermarket plug-in conversion system from A123 Systems. 

Although the plug-in Prius hybrids have used less gas and emitted less CO2 than their conventional counterparts, the vehicles are averaging just 51 mpg. Seattle has totaled more than 17,000 miles testing 14 plug-in hybrids in the past year.  

Ad Loading...

Although careful drivers have achieved 100 mpg in plug-in hybrids, the Seattle fleet test and others suggest that "real world" may be far smaller. The results may point to the many non-technological factors that come into play in wringing better fuel efficiency from plug-in hybrid cars, such as driver behavior. 

Seattle decided to try the technology in March 2008 after the U.S. Department of Energy agreed to subsidize the program. The city maintains a fleet of 300 conventional Prius hybrids and converted 14 of them to plug-ins. 

General Motors and Toyota are among the automakers promising to have plug-ins on the road as early as next year. The results of these early fleet tests suggest EV advocates and automakers will have to tell people how to drive the cars most efficiently because they may not catch on if consumers don't see the fuel efficiency they're promised. 

Idaho National Laboratory is seeing similar results with the 104 plug-in hybrid vehicles it is monitoring in 22 states. The cars have logged more than 300,000 miles in the past year and returned an average of 46 to 51 mpg. 

EV advocates say the drivers aren't being told how to maximize fuel efficiency, and they don't care because they aren't paying for the gas. To get the most from plug-in hybrids, they say, use a light touch on the accelerator, lower your speed, and plug it in at every opportunity to keep the batteries fully charged. 

Ad Loading...

Keeping the cars charged is also key. If the battery runs down, the gas engine must work harder-the battery becomes dead weight-and that cuts efficiency. Seattle officials discovered the plug-ins were being driven with dead batteries nearly one-third of the time. The cars with fully charged batteries got 50 percent better fuel economy than those with dead ones. 

Plug-in advocates say Seattle's fleet results are no reason to pull the plug on the cars. The technology works, they say, and it will deliver on fuel economy, but only if people are instructed on how to get the most out of the cars.

More Green Fleet

Sketch of chassis cab truck.
Green Fleetby Chris BrownMarch 9, 2026

Startup ZMD Motors Developing Electric Conversion for Ram 5500 Work Trucks

Detroit-based company says it has begun early development of a system to convert internal combustion Ram 5500 chassis-cab trucks to electric power.

Read More →
SponsoredFebruary 26, 2026

MOVING ON FROM DEBATE: A Guide for Fleet Managers Who Just Want To Get Electrification Done

Fleet managers are done with the debate—and focused on execution. Learn how to build a practical electrification strategy that aligns infrastructure, operations, and financing while keeping costs controlled and deployment scalable with support from Blink Charging. Discover how smart planning today positions fleets for long-term performance and ROI.

Read More →
EV charging symbol
Green Fleetby Chris BrownFebruary 12, 2026

U.S. EV Adoption Is Climbing, but Commercial and Passenger Markets Diverge

New industry group data revealed that light-duty electric vehicle sales are hitting record market share and volumes, while commercial EV volume dipped. What’s driving the fluctuations?

Read More →
Ad Loading...
SponsoredFebruary 6, 2026

Hybrids: Electrification Without the Challenges

For fleet managers, fuel is one of the biggest line items in the budget — and it's one hybrids can shrink without changing how your people work. Download the eBook to see the numbers, understand the technology, and get a step-by-step guide to making the switch.

Read More →
A side view of the yellow, blue, and red Slate Auto electric pick-up truck and SUV
Upfittingby Martin RomjueDecember 8, 2025

How To Upfit Electric Work Trucks and Vans

The biggest challenge lies in balancing additional equipment and accessories with EV battery capacity and range.

Read More →
Green Fleetby Martin RomjueDecember 4, 2025

How Fleets Can Adjust Approaches To EV Adoption

With the expiration of federal incentives, EV success now hinges less on government policy and more on discounts, battery tech progress, increased range, and broader infrastructure.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Panelists on stage at FFC.
Fleet Forwardby Martin RomjueOctober 29, 2025

Despite World Troubles, Forward Thinking Guides Fleets

Fleet operators shared their challenges during an annual conference that embraced the latest advances across all aspects of running private- and public-sector vehicles.

Read More →
Illustration of GM Energy’s vehicle-to-home system showing an electric truck connected to home power storage, the grid, and GM Energy Cloud through the myOwner app.
Green Fleetby News/Media ReleaseOctober 28, 2025

GM Energy Details Partnerships and Targets for Public Charging Build-Out

EVgo, Pilot, ChargePoint and IONNA named; goal is 35k GM-invested DC stalls by 2030, with customer-experience upgrades at sites.

Read More →
Chart showing September 2025 EV sales. New EV sales totaled 147,716 units, up 44% year over year, and used EV sales hit 40,569 units, up 76%, marking strong third-quarter performance.
Green Fleetby News/Media ReleaseOctober 23, 2025

Q3 Electric Vehicles Sales Hit Record High

EV buyers took advantage of the final federal tax credit days, while average prices edged up for new EVs and continued to decline for used models.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A green vertical bar graph chart showing the rises and dips in quarterly EV sales since early 2022.
Green Fleetby News/Media ReleaseOctober 10, 2025

EV Sales Hit Record in Q3 Before Incentives Expire

But most OEMs record low-volume sales, which means EV profitability remains a distant dream for nearly every automaker.

Read More →