Don’t Miss: NTSB Chair Signals Watershed Moment in Roadway Safety
NTSB Points to Flaws in NHTSA’s 5-Star Safety Rating Program
The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration’s 5-Star Safety Raring Program evaluates a vehicle’s crashworthiness, but not its crash-avoidance technologies.

NHTSA’s New Car Assessment Program evaluates new vehicles based on how well they perform in a series of crash tests.
Photo: Unsplash.com/Erik Mclean
The National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) has expressed concern about the lack of including collision-avoidance technologies as safety criteria in the 5-Star Safety Rating Program spearheaded by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA).
Presently, NHTSA’s 5-Star Rating Program — also known as its New Car Assessment Program — evaluates new vehicles based on how well they perform in a series of crash tests. Specifically, NHTSA conducts frontal, side, and rollover tests because these types account for the majority of crashes on America's roadways.
However, NTSB says crash tests are no longer enough. With the proliferation of advanced driver safety systems, safety is not only about crashworthiness, but also increasingly about crash avoidance.
In March, after NHTSA requested comments on its 5-Star Rating Program, NTSB Chair Jennifer Homendy responded with a 13-page letter detailing ways to improve the program.
While NHTSA’s rating program dates back to 1979, it still assesses only how well a vehicle performs during a crash. On the upside, the program has been a strong motivator for automakers to continually improve crashworthiness of vehicles over the years.
Even so, NTSB says the performance of crash avoidance systems should be rated by NHTSA and included in the overall 5-Star rating system, which American consumers depend on. Moreover, Congress passed a law requiring NHTSA to include crash-avoidance technologies on the widow labels found on new cars at dealerships by 2016, but this has not yet happened.
Ultimately, NTSB would like to see NHTSA rate the performance of technologies like forward collision warning, automatic emergency braking, lane departure warnings, lane keep assist systems, driver monitoring, and other active and passive components designed to also protect pedestrians and bicyclists.
A 5-Star Rating Program that combines evaluations of both crashworthiness and crash-avoidance technologies would ultimately provide motorists with a more comprehensive picture of vehicle safety.
More Safety

What’s Next for Fleet? Safety, AI & Industry Recognition | AF News Recap
Could your company's culture be encouraging distracted driving? This week, we're exploring how workplace expectations affect driver safety, what AI, EVs, and autonomous vehicles could mean for the future of fleet management, and how fleet professionals can strengthen their award nominations.
Read More →
Does Your Fleet's Culture Encourage Distracted Driving?
What happens when the people responsible for enforcing safety rules are the ones setting the wrong example? The answer may reveal why some of the biggest risks to fleet drivers have little to do with what's written in the employee handbook.
Read More →
Fleet Manager’s Ultimate Playbook: Navigating the New Standard in OEM Connectivity
Rising operating costs, driver safety concerns, and unplanned downtime are putting unprecedented pressure on modern fleets. Discover how fleet managers use embedded OEM connectivity and real-time vehicle data to cut TCO, prevent downtime, and protect drivers without aftermarket telematics hardware.
Read More →
From Driver Well-Being to EV Charging | AF News Recap
Mental health belongs in the fleet safety conversation. This week, we’re looking at five ways fleets can support employee well-being before a crisis, plus Holman’s expansion in Mexico, new one-day Fleet Forward passes, and why EV charging demand is outpacing infrastructure growth.
Read More →
Nexar-Nauto Merger Aims to Give Fleets Better Safety Intelligence Through Larger Driving Dataset
Stefan Heck tells Automotive Fleet that combining more than 10 billion miles of driving history with Nexar's AI models will give fleets deeper insights into driver risk and roadway conditions than either company could provide independently.
Read More →
Don't Wait for a Crisis: 5 Ways to Build Mental Health Into Your Fleet Safety Program
For Suicide Prevention Month, fleet and safety leaders have an opportunity to put mental health where it belongs: at the center of workplace safety.
Read More →
How Camera Data Can Strengthen a Fleet’s Insurance Renewal
Insights from a commercial insurance carrier and a broker show how fleets can turn video telematic data, driver coaching, and improved claims results into a stronger case at insurance renewal.
Read More →
The Safest Fleets Aren’t the Ones with the Most Technology
You’ve made the telematics investment. Here’s how to capture the other half of its value and build the safest fleet on the road.
Read More →
Hidden in Plain Sight: Fleet Compliance Risks
Fleet compliance isn't just about having policies — it's about consistently enforcing them. This practical guide reveals six hidden compliance risks common in public sector and shared fleet operations and outlines proven strategies to improve visibility, accountability, and audit readiness
Read More →
NETS Sets 2026 Fleet Safety Benchmark Conference for Indianapolis
The Sept. 15–17 program will feature fleet benchmarking data, case studies, emerging technologies, and implementation strategies while running alongside the NSC Safety Congress & Expo.
Read More →