Automotive Fleet
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

NHTSA Refutes Tesla's Safest Vehicle Claim

NHTSA recently issued a statement that a 5-star rating is the highest rating a vehicle can achieve under its crash-testing program, but stopped short of naming one vehicle as the safest vehicle on the road today.

by Marianne Matthews
October 10, 2018
NHTSA Refutes Tesla's Safest Vehicle Claim

Federal crash-testers are reminding the public that they don't rank a vehicle as the "safest vehicle," despite claims from Tesla about its Model 3.

Screenshot via Tesla.

2 min to read


The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) recently issued a statement that a 5-star rating is the highest rating a vehicle can achieve under its crash-testing program, but stopped short of naming one vehicle as the safest vehicle on the road today.

The agency's statement appears to be a veiled response to Tesla's claim that NHTSA's test also shows that its Model 3 "has the lowest probability of injury of all cars the safety agency has ever tested." That claim from Tesla appeared in a blog post dated Oct. 7.

Ad Loading...

NHTSA's statement, which goes on to say that the agency doesn't distinguish safety performance beyond the 5-star rating and "thus there is no 'safest' vehicle among those vehicles achieving 5-star ratings," was posted on the agency's website on Oct. 9.

NHTSA's crash-testing program conducts a total of three crash tests on new vehicles. These include one frontal and two side crash tests, as well as a rollover resistance assessment — a driving maneuver test that assesses a vehicle's susceptibility to tipping up and a measurement of top-heaviness. According to NHTSA, results from these three crash tests and the rollover resistance assessment are weighted and combined into an overall safety rating. A 5-star rating is the highest safety rating a vehicle can achieve.

While the Model 3 did achieve a 5-star rating in every subcategory, Tesla put its own spin on the NHTSA testing and resulting data. In the blog post, the automaker states that the agency's data shows that vehicle occupants are less likely to get seriously hurt in specific types of crashes when in a Model 3 as opposed to any other car. However, NHTSA's statement is a reminder to all that the agency and its assessment program are not in the business of singling out any one vehicle as a top safety winner.

More Safety

conference attendees watching a speaker
Safetyby StaffAugust 6, 2026

NETS Sets 2026 Fleet Safety Benchmark Conference for Indianapolis

The Sept. 15–17 program will feature fleet benchmarking data, case studies, emerging technologies, and implementation strategies while running alongside the NSC Safety Congress & Expo.

Read More →
NETS crash statistics overlaying an accident photo
Safetyby Chris BrownAugust 5, 2026

Off-the-Job Crashes Account for 43% of Employers’ $61.7 Billion Crash Burden

NETS quantifies costs dispersed across fleet, risk, HR, and other departments while providing new per-crash benchmarks for employers.

Read More →
red ram recall image
Safetyby Faith HowellAugust 3, 2026

Ram Recalls More Than 1.27 Million 1500 Pickups for Seat Belt Anchor Issue

The recall affects certain 2019-2026 Ram 1500 pickups that may have improperly attached second-row seat belt buckle anchors.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A shot of a Volvo electric vehicle with a man charging it in front of a residence.
SponsoredAugust 1, 2026

Top 50 Executive Fleets

It is that time of year again! Time for the 2026 list of the Top 50 Executive Fleets, presented by Automotive Fleet and Volvo as part of its annual Fleet 500. Download now to see this year's list of companies!

Read More →
Promotional graphic for a Utilimarc guide titled How Better Visibility Cut Speeding Violations by 48% featuring a call-to-action to download the guide.
SponsoredJuly 17, 2026

How Better Visibility Cut Speeding Violations by 48%

Fleet leaders don't need more data, they need clearer visibility into what the data is saying. This case study explores how one utility replaced speeding-event counts with a single metric — miles driven in violation — to strengthen safety and significantly reduce speeding violations.

Read More →
Smiling commercial truck driver gives a thumbs-up from inside a tractor cab during Operation Safe Driver Week 2026, highlighting fleet safety, responsible driving and enforcement awareness.
Safetyby Judie NuskeyJuly 16, 2026

Operation Safe Driver Week: Why the Industry's Oldest Safety Campaign Still Matters to Fleets

A look at how a 2007 enforcement initiative became one of the most consequential weeks on the fleet safety calendar, and what it means for your drivers in 2026.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Nexar and nauto logos
Safetyby StaffJuly 13, 2026

Nexar-Nauto Merger Aims to Give Fleets Better Safety Intelligence Through Larger Driving Dataset

Stefan Heck tells Automotive Fleet that combining more than 10 billion miles of driving history with Nexar's AI models will give fleets deeper insights into driver risk and roadway conditions than either company could provide independently.

Read More →
A black square with white color font text
SponsoredJuly 2, 2026

From Silos to Solutions: Relationship Management for Safer Fleets

From telematics adoption and driver accountability to policy consistency and risk mitigation, this episode breaks down what it really takes to build a safer fleet culture without slowing business down.

Read More →
IIHS HLDI text overlaid on the trunks of pick up trucks.
Safetyby Chris BrownJuly 2, 2026

IIHS Launches First Commercial Vehicle Safety Evaluations

The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety has begun evaluating heavy-duty pickups and cargo vans for driver protection. Which models earned top marks?

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A blue and white Automotive Fleet podcast logo
SafetyJuly 1, 2026

Reducing Risk by Eliminating Phone Use Behind the Wheel

Hosted with the cofounder of Lifesaver Mobile, this episode addresses phone use behind the wheel and how to design a driving environment that actually helps prevents accidents.

Read More →