Other cities making Allstate’s annual safest-driving list include Kansas City, Madison, Cape Coral and Boise.
by Staff
June 28, 2016
Screen shot courtesy of Allstate.
4 min to read
Screen shot courtesy of Allstate.
Allstate’s annual America’s Best Drivers Report has identified Brownsville, Texas, as the safest-driving city in the country.
Based on Allstate Insurance Co. claims data, the 12th annual report measures vehicle collision frequency in America’s 200 largest cities to determine which ones have the safest drivers. The average driver in Brownsville, Texas, experiences an auto collision every 14.6 years, which is 31.4% less often than the national average of every 10 years.
Ad Loading...
Also cracking the Top 10 list of safest-driving cities are Kansas City, Kan.; Madison, Wis.; Cape Coral, Fla.; Boise, Idaho; Huntsville, Ala.; Port Saint Lucie, Fla.; Wichita, Kan.; Olathe, Kan.; and Reno, Nev.
The bottom 10, or least safest-driving cities, are Boston; Worcester, Mass.; Baltimore; Washington, D.C.; Springfield, Mass.; Glendale, Calif.; Providence, R.I.; Los Angeles; Philadelphia; and San Francisco.
“With millions of drivers expected to hit the roads nationwide during the July 4th weekend, our report demonstrates the importance of always putting safety first,” said Glenn Shapiro, executive vice president of claims for Allstate.
National safety experts say drivers are now spending more time on the road and suffering more fatal collisions than in recent years. The U.S. Department of Transportation reports that from March 2015 to February 2016, Americans drove 3.15 trillion miles — an increase of more than 3% over the previous 12 months and the largest year-to-year increase in more than two decades.
According to the National Safety Council, more than 38,000 roadway fatalities occurred last year — the highest count since 2008. Preventable human factors — such as drunk, distracted or drowsy driving; speeding; and failure to use safety features — contribute to 94% of car crashes.
Ad Loading...
According to the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, intoxication is a significant factor in Fourth of July crash fatalities, with 42% between 2010 and 2014 involving at least one driver with a blood-alcohol concentration over the legal driving limit of .08.
“While July Fourth is consistently the deadliest day on the road, the toll of crash deaths goes on every day, all year long,” said Adrian Lund, president of IIHS. “If everyone buckles up, avoids distractions, obeys the speed limit and doesn’t drink and drive, we can make July Fourth and every day on the road a lot safer.”
The following are the top 10 safest driving cities, according to Allstate’s 2016 America’s Best Drivers Report:
City & Overall Ranking
Collision Likelihood Compared to National Average
Average Years Between Collisions (National Average: 10)
1. Brownsville, Texas
31.4% less likely
14.6
2. Kansas City, Kan.
26.3% less likely
13.6
3. Madison, Wis.
24.7% less likely
13.3
4. Cape Coral, Fla.
22.3% less likely
12.9
5. Boise, Idaho
22.1% less likely
12.8
6. Huntsville, Ala.
21.4% less likely
12.7
7. Port Saint Lucie, Fla.
20.1% less likely
12.5
8. Wichita, Kan.
19.7% less likely
12.5
9. Olathe, Kan.
19.6% less likely
12.4
10. Reno, Nev.
18.3% less likely
12.2
Click here for an interactive map showing this year’s findings and for historical collision-frequency rankings from the past 11 years.
The report defines a collision as any auto crash resulting in a property damage claim. Allstate’s auto policies represent nearly 10% of all U.S. auto policies, making this report a realistic snapshot of what’s happening on America’s roadways, the company said.
Ad Loading...
For the second straight year, the report also provides insight into braking habits in more than 100 cities across the country, using hard-braking data culled from Allstate’s Drivewise offering.
A hard-braking event is defined as slowing down eight miles per hour or more over a one-second period. Allstate found a correlation between hard braking and collision frequency. Cities with higher collision frequency also recorded more hard-braking events.
Nationally, on average, a driver will experience 19 hard-braking events for every 1,000 miles driven. The following are the cities with drivers who experience the fewest hard-braking events per 1,000 miles driven:
Drivewise Hard-Braking Events
(Cities’ drivers with the fewest events per 1,000 miles)
Madison, Wis.
Ad Loading...
9.0
Anchorage, Alaska
9.3
Honolulu, Hawaii
10.1
Ad Loading...
Des Moines, Iowa
10.5
Wichita, Kan.
11.1
Boise, Idaho
Ad Loading...
11.6
Lincoln, Neb.
11.7
Kansas City, Kan.
12.0
Ad Loading...
Chesapeake, Va.
12.2
Jackson, Miss.
12.2
Driving tips for cities with high braking activity:
Ad Loading...
Leave room between you and other vehicles. Hard-braking collisions can occur when drivers are following other cars too closely, causing a rear-end collision. Try to avoid rear-end collisions by leaving more space and time to react to other vehicles’ actions.
Minimize distractions while driving. Distracted driving is one of the main causes of collisions. Common driving distractions include eating, grooming, talking on a cell phone or texting, interacting with other passengers, adjusting navigation devices, and playing loud music.
Distracted driving remains one of the most persistent risks in fleet operations. New approaches focus on removing mobile device use entirely while adding real-time safety support.
As distraction risks evolve, fleets are turning to smarter, more connected technologies to better understand what’s happening behind the wheel. Part 2 explores how these tools are helping identify risky behaviors and improve visibility across operations.
Distracted driving is often measured by what we can see—phones in hand, eyes off the road. But what about the distractions we can’t? A recent incident raises a bigger question about awareness, attention, and why subtle risks so often go unnoticed.
Fleets have more driver data than ever, so why isn't behavior changing? Training requires more than reports and coaching — it requires real-world practice.
A two-part conversation with Stefan Heck on how AI is transforming the fight against distracted driving. As fleets adopt smarter tools, the focus shifts from reacting to preventing risk. In Part 1, we look at where AI is making an impact for fleets today.
An 11% drop in pedestrian fatalities in early 2025 signals progress in U.S. road safety, but elevated death rates and ongoing risks underscore the need for continued action from fleets and policymakers.
