Automotive Fleet
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

The Great Debate: Model Year or Calendar Year?

In the "good old days," the overwhelming majority of new models would be "officially" introduced Oct. 1 of the preceding calendar-year. Little by little, this practice has migrated to the realm of nostalgia.

Mike Antich
Mike AntichFormer Editor and Associate Publisher
Read Mike's Posts
June 15, 2010
The Great Debate: Model Year or Calendar Year?

Year-round new-model introductions have complicated fleet planning and purchasing. 

Photo: Automotive Fleet

4 min to read


In the "good old days," most new models would be "officially" introduced on Oct. 1 of the preceding calendar year. Little by little, this practice has migrated to the realm of nostalgia as OEMs introduce new models throughout the calendar year. 

This trend started with mid-model year introductions in the January to March timeframe but slowly increased to introductions throughout the calendar year.

Ad Loading...

Year-round new-model introductions have complicated fleet planning and purchasing. Some fleet managers wonder aloud, perhaps wistfully, why the U.S. doesn't convert to a calendar-year format when classifying new models. 

"Should OEMs change to the same format as the rest of the world - a calendar year for the vehicle model year?" asked Gayle Pratt, director of global fleet for Ecolab.

This sentiment was echoed by Keri Moran, fleet administrator for J.R. Simplot Company.

"I'm tired of the staggered model-year production schedules. I used to be able to place all orders at the same time; now, I seem to be placing orders throughout the calendar year because of production schedules," Moran said.

Model Year is Not a Universal Practice

Identifying automobiles by "model year" started in the U.S. Alfred Sloan, the long-time president and chairman of GM, extended the idea of yearly fashion change from clothing to automobiles in the 1920s. 

Ad Loading...

The Great Depression prompted other U.S. OEMs to start selling "next" year's vehicles in October of the preceding year. But this isn't a universal practice. Vehicles sold in Japan are classified on a calendar-year basis. 

Similarly, the U.S. model-year concept was never universally adopted in Europe. One exception is VW, which switched in 1966 but chose August 1 to start selling the following model-year vehicles.

In later decades, the model year (October-September) became entrenched in the U.S. as new-model advertising was coordinated with the launch of the new television season in September. 

"This allowed for a stronger marketing program by placing more resources in a concentrated timeframe," said Brenda Perez, manager of national fleet operations for Mazda.

However, there are advantages to switching to a calendar-year cycle (January-December), which would facilitate fleet funding. 

Ad Loading...

"Many corporations operate on a calendar-year basis, so when it comes to capital budgeting and approval processes, companies who own vehicles, as opposed to lease, find themselves wanting to make their capital purchases early in the year or run the risk of losing those capital dollars when budgets get tight," said Greg Corrigan, VP of strategic consulting for PHH Arval. "For businesses that lease, the time of year they acquire the vehicle is largely irrelevant from a budget cycle perspective."

A calendar-year cycle might also benefit government fleets since their budgets are typically on an annual basis, noted Rick Shick, VP of purchasing for Donlen Corp. 

"This could make their budget process easier to manage. However, many commercial fleets have fiscal years that don't line up with calendar year," Shick added.

Other business considerations also impact introduction dates. The term "new-model introduction" has almost become a misnomer in today's sales climate. 

"When a new model is 'introduced' has little to do with the calendar. A calendar-year timetable, or the notion of an autumn new-model introduction, seems irrelevant when determining when a new model should be introduced," said Charles Reed, fleet sales operations manager for Subaru of America. Reed added what does seem relevant to new-model-year introduction is identifying: 

Ad Loading...
  1. Where does a vehicle reside in its lifecycle?

  2. Is a vehicle primarily a carryover version?

  3. How much unsold inventory of the vehicle is sitting at dealerships?

In addition, there would be major behind-the-scene ramifications to phase out the model-year concept. 

"A changeover to a calendar year would require modification of countless systems and business practices if this were to occur," said Shick of Donlen.

Year-round new-model introductions are facilitated by the U.S. government (NHTSA), which allows vehicles to be designated the next model year if manufactured by Jan. 1 of the preceding calendar year. For instance, a vehicle produced on Jan. 1, 2011, could be designated by the OEM as a 2012 model-year vehicle. 

"The advantage of mid-year vehicles for fleet is the benefit of 16-18 months of use, but the vehicle is depreciated for 12 months," said Jan Freund, director of manufacturer relations for Wheels Inc. 

Ad Loading...

Sometimes, there can be a detrimental impact on early introductions.

"For instance, the residual benefit from an early intro can be dramatically diminished midstream as the production cycle for that model year is longer than normal," said Perez. "Also, specific to a commercial fleet, an early MY launch (Jan. 1, 2011, for 2012-MY) is not timed for the segment, and there is limited to no interest in the vehicle until the standard order cycle rolls around."

Although fleet is important to automakers, the retail market dictates new-model introductions. 

"Secretly, I think the manufacturers love staggered introductions. It gives them a window of time when they're the kid on the block with the newest toy," said Rick Nicoletti, general manager for the Napleton Fleet Group.

Other reasons for early intros include CAFE averages, competitive leapfrogging, keeping the lineup fresh, maintaining year-round floor traffic at dealerships, and parts availability. 

Ad Loading...

"I don't think we'll see all the manufacturers line up and introduce new models at one specific time each year ever again," said Freund.

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Blog Posts

Market Trendsby Mike AntichSeptember 7, 2023

Fleets Want Trust Restored with Suppliers

During this period of ongoing supply constraints, the trust that fleet managers had with OEMs, upfitters, and dealers has been strained. Fleet managers say they have had too many experiences over the past three years coping with erroneous information, adjusting to multiple price increases, and feeling betrayed by inadequate transparency from suppliers.

Read More →
Market Trendsby Mike AntichAugust 23, 2023

Scheduled Replacement Cycles Are Becoming a Distant Memory

The ongoing difficulty in sourcing replacement vehicles is forcing companies to extend the service lives of vehicles that are unable to be replaced, which, inevitably, increases unscheduled maintenance expenses.

Read More →
Market Trendsby Mike AntichJuly 7, 2023

Fleet Simplification is the Antidote to Asset Variability

Fleet simplification identifies asset functions to uncover commonality among the equipment and assets. Simplification increases operational efficiency as end-users become accustomed to the controls, displays, and operation of less diverse units.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Market Trendsby Mike AntichJune 29, 2023

The Dangers of Static Fleet Policies

A fleet policy is a living document, flexible enough to adapt to evolving business priorities, developing industry trends, and changing industry best practices and standards.

Read More →
Market Trendsby Mike AntichApril 17, 2023

Short-Term vs. Long-Term Cost Reductions

Corporate procurement staff are often driven by short-term, immediate cost reductions. However, a longer perspective to soft cost savings is critical because fixating on short-term results will hurt a company in the long run.

Read More →
Market Trendsby Mike AntichMarch 29, 2023

Uptick in Unscheduled Maintenance Increasing Vehicle Downtime

Fleet data analysis can identify recurring downtime issues. It’s important to determine the root causes of downtime so procedures can be developed to minimize such problems.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Market Trendsby Mike AntichDecember 6, 2022

Eliminate Needless Curb Weight to Maximize ICE & EV Efficiencies

Vehicle weight relates directly to fuel economy. In today’s era of electrification, there is also a direct correlation between vehicle weight and battery range.

Read More →
Market Trendsby Mike AntichOctober 5, 2022

Tech Dependence Risks Dumbing Down Fleet Manager Expertise

The line between creative thinking and problem solving and doing what the data indicates is thin. To lead in fleet management, you need to balance understanding the fundamentals and embracing what smart technology offers.

Read More →
Market Trendsby Mike AntichAugust 15, 2022

Leverage the Synergy of Safe Driving to Achieve Sustainability and Cost Goals

Safe driving, emission reductions, and cost containment can all be achieved at the same time.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Market Trendsby Mike AntichMay 19, 2022

The Playbook for Fleet Manager Success

There are many paths to success — most of them involve being flexible, open-minded, and willing to learn.

Read More →