Automotive Fleet
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

The Dangers of Static Fleet Policies

A fleet policy is a living document, flexible enough to adapt to evolving business priorities, developing industry trends, and changing industry best practices and standards.

Mike Antich
Mike AntichFormer Editor and Associate Publisher
Read Mike's Posts
June 29, 2023
The Dangers of Static Fleet Policies

With regular review, a fleet policy can take advantage of cost-saving opportunitites, emerging trends, and new operational efficiencies.

Photo: Nataliya Vaitkevich

4 min to read


The danger of a fleet policy remaining static, or unchanged over time, is that it can lead to various negative consequences. Here are some potential dangers associated with maintaining a static fleet policy:

Operational Inefficiencies

As technology, best practices, and industry standards evolve, a static fleet policy may fail to incorporate new advancements. This can result in inefficient fleet operations, leading to higher costs, increased fuel consumption, and reduced productivity. Failure to adapt to changing circumstances and market conditions may put your fleet at a competitive disadvantage.

Ad Loading...

Safety Risks

Safety regulations and standards often undergo updates to address emerging risks and improve overall safety. By not revising the fleet policy, you may miss out on incorporating crucial safety measures, such as implementing new vehicle safety technologies or providing updated training to drivers.

This can expose your fleet and drivers to unnecessary safety hazards and potential accidents.

Compliance Issues

Laws and regulations governing fleet management can change over time. Failing to update the fleet policy accordingly may result in non-compliance with legal requirements, leading to penalties, fines, and legal liabilities.

Staying informed about and incorporating regulatory updates into your fleet policy is crucial to maintain compliance.

Missed Cost-Saving Opportunities

A static fleet policy may overlook opportunities for cost savings. Advancements in vehicle technology, alternative fuels, or maintenance practices can present cost-saving options, such as improved fuel efficiency or reduced maintenance expenses.

Ad Loading...

Without regularly reviewing and updating the fleet policy, you might miss out on these potential savings.

Lack of Employee Satisfaction & Retention

Employee satisfaction and engagement are important factors for any organization's success.

A static fleet policy may not address changing employee needs, preferences, or concerns. Failing to adapt the policy to accommodate evolving work-life balance expectations, driver training requirements, or other employee-related factors can result in decreased morale, lower job satisfaction, and increased turnover rates.

Inability to Adapt to Emerging Trends

The transportation industry is constantly evolving, with new technologies, business models, and sustainability practices emerging. A static fleet policy may hinder your ability to capitalize on these trends or adapt to market demands.

For example, if there is a growing demand for electric vehicles or a shift toward shared mobility services, not updating the policy to accommodate these changes may lead to missed opportunities and decreased competitiveness.

Ad Loading...

To mitigate these dangers, it is essential to regularly review and update your fleet policy. Stay informed about industry trends, regulatory changes, and tech advancements to ensure your fleet policy remains aligned with best practices and your organization's goals.

Flexibility and adaptability are key in maintaining a successful fleet operation. A fleet policy should not remain static. It must be a living document that is updated as new needs arise.

A Fleet Policy Must be a Living Document

While organizations typically have a general annual policy review, the fleet policy needs to be reviewed more frequently.  In organizations where the fleet policy is also the fleet driver-risk policy and/or the commercial vehicle policy, the document will be need to be modified even more frequently. We issue an updated policy quarterly.  The updates occur between the policy releases and are highlighted to reflect the change in the previous version. 

When the updated policy is released, it should be included in a communication advising all stakeholders of the update.

Think of fleet policy the same as you would DNA. Each fleet has a DNA of sorts, which is comprised of the procedures and regulations that are codified in its corporate fleet policy. It is these policies that determine the type of fleet that is operated and its characteristics.

Ad Loading...

Think about it. By creating policy, such as who is eligible to operate a company vehicle, you are, in effect, determining the size of your fleet. In my experience the best-managed fleets tend to be those that adhere to a written fleet policy. It is important that fleet policy reflects a company’s overall business strategy, but more important, it needs to be up-to-date.

When developing or re-evaluating fleet policies, there are many issues that must be addressed, and these issues will vary by company. As such, you should solicit the participation of all affected departments, such as procurement; EHS; risk management, and human resources, in addition to vehicle user groups such as sales and operations.

By involving all of these stakeholders in the decision-making process, it increases the likelihood of buy-in and support of policies. It is also important to solicit this involvement to ensure the policy is comprehensive and to ensure  important components are not inadvertently omitted.

Not only do fleet policies bring structure to the way you lead your fleet and how you manage your vehicle assets; they also serve as a reference source for drivers and their managers to consult when a question needs a quick answer.

In summary, fleet policy needs to be flexible so it can be modified to reflect evolving business priorities. In a time of crisis, such as the current pandemic, the best practice is to develop a forward-looking action plan. You need to know what you are going to do, and then act proactively to accomplish those goals.

Ad Loading...
Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Blog Posts

Market Trendsby Mike AntichSeptember 7, 2023

Fleets Want Trust Restored with Suppliers

During this period of ongoing supply constraints, the trust that fleet managers had with OEMs, upfitters, and dealers has been strained. Fleet managers say they have had too many experiences over the past three years coping with erroneous information, adjusting to multiple price increases, and feeling betrayed by inadequate transparency from suppliers.

Read More →
Market Trendsby Mike AntichAugust 23, 2023

Scheduled Replacement Cycles Are Becoming a Distant Memory

The ongoing difficulty in sourcing replacement vehicles is forcing companies to extend the service lives of vehicles that are unable to be replaced, which, inevitably, increases unscheduled maintenance expenses.

Read More →
Market Trendsby Mike AntichJuly 7, 2023

Fleet Simplification is the Antidote to Asset Variability

Fleet simplification identifies asset functions to uncover commonality among the equipment and assets. Simplification increases operational efficiency as end-users become accustomed to the controls, displays, and operation of less diverse units.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Market Trendsby Mike AntichApril 17, 2023

Short-Term vs. Long-Term Cost Reductions

Corporate procurement staff are often driven by short-term, immediate cost reductions. However, a longer perspective to soft cost savings is critical because fixating on short-term results will hurt a company in the long run.

Read More →
Market Trendsby Mike AntichMarch 29, 2023

Uptick in Unscheduled Maintenance Increasing Vehicle Downtime

Fleet data analysis can identify recurring downtime issues. It’s important to determine the root causes of downtime so procedures can be developed to minimize such problems.

Read More →
Market Trendsby Mike AntichDecember 6, 2022

Eliminate Needless Curb Weight to Maximize ICE & EV Efficiencies

Vehicle weight relates directly to fuel economy. In today’s era of electrification, there is also a direct correlation between vehicle weight and battery range.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Market Trendsby Mike AntichOctober 5, 2022

Tech Dependence Risks Dumbing Down Fleet Manager Expertise

The line between creative thinking and problem solving and doing what the data indicates is thin. To lead in fleet management, you need to balance understanding the fundamentals and embracing what smart technology offers.

Read More →
Market Trendsby Mike AntichAugust 15, 2022

Leverage the Synergy of Safe Driving to Achieve Sustainability and Cost Goals

Safe driving, emission reductions, and cost containment can all be achieved at the same time.

Read More →
Market Trendsby Mike AntichMay 19, 2022

The Playbook for Fleet Manager Success

There are many paths to success — most of them involve being flexible, open-minded, and willing to learn.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Market Trendsby Mike AntichFebruary 25, 2022

Drivers are the First Line of Defense in Controlling Fleet Costs

Fleet policy begins and ends with the fleet manager, a living and continually updated document, and no exceptions.

Read More →