Automotive Fleet
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Vincentric's Best Fleet Value Awards Announced

BLOOMFIELD HILLS, MI – Vincentric has announced the winners of its Best Fleet Value in America awards, with Toyota winning 12 of the 29 vehicle segments. Chevrolet took top honors in eight segments, powered by its sweep of the full-size pick-up and full-size van categories.

March 7, 2006
3 min to read


BLOOMFIELD HILLS, MI – Vincentric has announced the winners of its Best Fleet Value in America awards, with Toyota winning 12 of the 29 vehicle segments. Chevrolet took top honors in eight segments, powered by its sweep of the full-size pick-up and full-size van categories. To determine Vincentric’s Best Fleet Value in America awards, Vincentric developed a comprehensive analysis of fleet lifecycle costs. The company measured eight cost factors for more than 1,900 vehicle configurations in the 2006-model year, with 12 different mileage/lifecycle timeframe scenarios used in each of the 50 states plus Washington, D.C. The resulting 9 million-plus lifecycle cost measurements were then reviewed to determine the winning vehicles. The eight cost factors determining overall lifecycle costs were depreciation, fuel, insurance, opportunity cost, financing, maintenance, taxes and state fees, and repairs. These costs were integrated with the Vincentric Fleet Price, which estimates the acquisition cost for each vehicle in the study. "Annual mileage was measured ranging from a low of 20,000 miles to a high of 30,000 miles, along with timeframes from 24 to 60 months of ownership," said David Wurster, president of Vincentric. The vehicle segments and the winners of Vincentric’s Best Fleet Value in America awards for the 2006-model year include:

Cars/Crossovers:

Ad Loading...


  • Subcompact: Chevrolet Aveo Special Value 4D Hatchback.

  • Compact, over $17,000: Mazda3 S 4D Hatchback.

  • Compact, under $17,000: Toyota Corolla CE 4D Sedan 5 sp.

  • Mid-Size, over $23,000: Toyota Camry SE V6 VVTi 4D Sedan a.t.

  • Mid-Size, under $23,000: Toyota Camry Base 4D Sedan 5 sp.

  • Large: Toyota Avalon XL 4D Sedan.

  • Near Luxury: Volvo S40 2.4i 4D Sedan.

  • Luxury: Volvo S80 2.5T 4D Sedan.

  • Prestige Luxury: Mercedes-Benz E Class E500 4D Sedan.

  • Wagon, over $24,500: Subaru Legacy Outback 5D Wagon 5 sp.

  • Wagon, under $24,500: Toyota Matrix STD 4D Hatchback 2WD 5 sp.

  • Crossover, over $28,000: Nissan Murano SL 4D Utility 2WD.

  • Crossover, under $28,000: Chrysler PT Cruiser Base 4D Utility. Sport Utility Vehicles:


  • Compact SUV, over $22,500: Toyota Rav4 Limited 4D Utility 2WD 4 cyl.

  • Compact SUV, under $22,500: Toyota Rav4 Base 4D Utility 2WD 4 cyl.

  • Mid-Size SUV, over $30,000: Toyota Highlander Limited 4D Utility 2WD with third-row seat.

  • Mid-Size SUV, under $30,000: Toyota Highlander Base 4D Utility 2WD 4 cyl.

  • Large SUV, over $40,500: Toyota Sequoia Limited 4D Utility 2WD.

  • Large SUV, under $40,500: Chevrolet Trailblazer LS 4D Utility Ext 2WD. Pickup Trucks and Cab/Chassis:


  • Compact Pickup: Toyota Tacoma Base Reg Cab 2WD 5sp.

  • Full-Size Pickup: Chevrolet Silverado 1500 W/T Reg Cab 2WD 119.

  • Heavy Duty ¾ Ton Pickup: Chevrolet Silverado 2500 HD W/T Reg Cab 2WD LWB.

  • Heavy Duty 1 Ton Pickup: Chevrolet Silverado 3500 LT Ext Cab 2WD LWB DRW.

  • Cab/Chassis: Chevrolet Silverado 3500LD C/C LT Reg Cab 2WD 137.0. Vans:


  • Minivan, over $27,000: Toyota Sienna XLE 5D Wagon 7 Pass FWD.

  • Minivan, under $27,000: Mazda5 Sport 4D Wagon.

  • Full-Size Passenger Van: GMC Savana/Chevrolet Express G1500 Wagon SWB.

  • Mini Cargo Van: Dodge Caravan Base Cargo Van.

  • Full-Size Cargo Van: GMC Savana/Chevrolet Express G1500 Cargo SWB.

Topics:Operations

More Operations

Cover of the "Top 50 Green Fleets" report presented by Automotive Fleet and Inspiration Fleet, featuring an aerial nighttime photo of a lit highway interchange with looping ramps.
SponsoredJuly 16, 2026

The Top 50 Green Fleets

The List Is in: The Top 50 Green Fleets

Read More →
A car dealership with added inscription "Every fleet vehicle eventually becomes local."
Operationsby Chris BrownJuly 15, 2026

Your Local Dealer Knows More Than You Think

Your local dealer can provide an information advantage that extends well beyond courtesy deliveries.

Read More →
Portrait of Austin Schutte, founder and CEO of Anew Solutions, featured in Automotive Fleet's Fleet Meets series highlighting his career, leadership philosophy, and fleet industry insights.
Operationsby Faith HowellJuly 14, 2026

Fleet Meets: Austin Schutte

Here are some industry insights, personal touches, and words of advice from the CEO and Founder of Anew Solutions.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Photo of Team Brown building soap box derby
Operationsby Chris BrownJuly 13, 2026

Soap Box Derby Challenge: What’s Powering Team Brown

The car is coming together, the students are solving real build problems, and the fleet industry is helping push Team Brown toward the starting line.

Read More →
Green and black bar graphs showing 2026 versus 2025 fleet sales.
Vehicle Researchby Martin RomjueJuly 8, 2026

Commercial Fleet Sales Contribute To June, YTD Gains

The fleet sector has boosted its vehicle purchases at a reliable pace in the first half of this year compared with 1H 2025.

Read More →
A black square with white color font text
OperationsJuly 2, 2026

What Fleet Managers Really Want From Vendors

From customer service frustrations and technology breakdowns to RFQs, change management, and the growing impact of turnover across the industry, this conversation pulls back the curtain on the real operational challenges fleet managers are navigating every day.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A black square with white color font text
OperationsJuly 2, 2026

Fleet Safety Masterclass: Industry Leaders on Storytelling, Strategy & Innovation

In this special masterclass episode, industry leaders break down what it really takes to build safer fleets in today’s increasingly distracted and data-driven world.

Read More →
A black square with white color font text
OperationsJuly 2, 2026

Integrating Legacy Fleet Systems and Historical Data

In this episode, we bring together fleet and technology leaders to unpack the realities of data integration, system migrations, and the evolving role of AI in fleet management.

Read More →
A black square with white color font text
OperationsJuly 2, 2026

From Resistance to Results: Change Management Strategies for Fleets

From new technologies and safety programs to evolving regulations, fleets are under constant pressure to adapt. But as Dr. Betz explains, success isn’t about the system you implement—it’s about whether your people actually use it.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A black square with white color font text
OperationsJuly 2, 2026

Where We're Headed: A Practical Look at AI in Fleet

Discover how AI is actually being deployed in fleets, not just marketed, including practical use cases and emerging risks.

Read More →