HLDI Says Ford F-250 Has Highest Theft Rate of Any 2010-2012-MY Vehicle
In addition to the F-250, a number of other trucks commonly used by fleets top the Highway Loss Data Institute's (HLDI's) list, including the Chevrolet Silverado, GMC Sierra, and Ford F-350. In previous years, the Cadillac Escalade topped the HLDI’s list.
The Highway Loss Data Institute (HLDI) found in a recent study that the Ford F-250 had the highest theft rate of any 2010-2012-MY vehicles. In addition to the F-250, a number of other trucks commonly used by fleets top the HLDI’s list, including the Chevrolet Silverado, GMC Sierra, and Ford F-350. In previous years, the Cadillac Escalade topped the HLDI’s list.
The F-250’s four-wheel-drive crew cab model has a theft rate that is 7 per 1,000 insured vehicle years (one vehicle insured for one year), which is six times the average for all vehicles. HLDI noted that a theft claim from a pickup doesn’t necessarily mean the entire truck was stolen but rather than equipment was stolen from the truck’s bed, or possibly components from the vehicle. HLDI said it doesn’t distinguish the theft of contents from the theft of an entire vehicle.
Despite the changing lineup of vehicles popular with thieves, theft rates are declining, which HLDI attributes to the more widespread use of ignition immobilizers. This technology is standard in 89 percent of 2012-MY vehicles. HLDI noted that fewer pickup trucks have this technology, but MY-2010-2012 F-250 pickups come standard with it.
HLDI’s complete list of theft rates for 2010-2012-MY vehicles is below.
INSURANCE THEFT CLAIMS, 2010-12 PASSENGER VEHICLES | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
Vehicle size/type | Claim freq. | Avg. loss payment per claim | Overall theft losses | |
HIGHEST CLAIM RATES | ||||
Ford F-250 crew 4WD | very large pickup | 7 | $7,060 | $50 |
Chevrolet Silverado 1500 crew | large pickup | 6.7 | $5,463 | $37 |
Chevrolet Avalanche 1500 | very large SUV | 6.1 | $6,163 | $38 |
GMC Sierra 1500 crew | large pickup | 6 | $6,366 | $38 |
Ford F-350 crew 4WD | very large pickup | 5.6 | $7,517 | $42 |
Cadillac Escalade 4WD | large luxury SUV | 5.5 | $6,508 | $36 |
Chevrolet Suburban 1500 | very large SUV | 5.4 | $4,468 | $24 |
GMC Sierra 1500 extended cab | large pickup | 4.7 | $5,908 | $28 |
GMC Yukon | large SUV | 4.5 | $6,276 | $28 |
Chevrolet Tahoe | large SUV | 4.4 | $5,367 | $23 |
LOWEST CLAIM RATES | ||||
Dodge Journey 4WD | midsize SUV | 0.4 | $5,016 | $2 |
Volkswagen Tiguan 4WD | small SUV | 0.4 | $10,352 | $4 |
Audi A4 4-door | midsize luxury car | 0.4 | $13,803 | $5 |
Acura RDX | midsize luxury SUV | 0.4 | $8,701 | $3 |
Toyota Matrix | small station wagon | 0.4 | $7,782 | $3 |
Lexus HS 250 hybrid 4-door | midsize luxury car | 0.4 | $2,226 | $1 |
Honda CR-V | small SUV | 0.4 | $4,630 | $2 |
Hyundai Tucson 4WD | small SUV | 0.4 | $4,134 | $2 |
Toyota Sienna 4WD | very large minivan | 0.5 | $13,038 | $6 |
Jeep Compass 4WD | small SUV | 0.5 | $5,527 | $3 |
AVERAGE ALL PASSENGER VEHICLES | 1.2 | $6,532 | $8 | |
Note: Claim frequencies are per 1,000 insured vehicle years; overall losses are average payments per insured vehicle year. |
More Operations

Fleet Has a Talent Pipeline Problem. What Comes Next? | AF News Recap
Where will fleet’s next generation of leaders come from? This week, we’re looking at the industry’s talent pipeline, what certification can add to a fleet career, how to build an award-worthy track record, and the return of Automotive Fleet’s Personal Use Survey.
Read More →
Smith System Launches Driver Risk Management Program
Fleets have more driver data than ever, but identifying risky behavior doesn't necessarily correct it. Smith System's new Driver Risk Management program combines monitoring, training, and follow-up coaching to help fleets connect risk signals with driver intervention.
Read More →
Automotive Fleet Opens 2026 Personal Use Survey for Commercial Fleet Managers
Less than two weeks left! Commercial and corporate fleet managers are invited to share how their organizations handle company vehicle personal-use policies, charges, and driver eligibility.
Read More →
From AI Prompts to AI-Generated Safety Songs | AF News Recap
Can better prompts make AI more useful for fleet managers? This week, we’re breaking down smarter fleet analysis, an AI-assisted experiment that turned safety training into music, and what happened to fuel prices in August.
Read More →
How to Write Better AI Prompts for Fleet Analysis
Include these six elements in your fleet prompts to generate more relevant analysis and accurate answers.
Read More →
Fleet Meets: Eric Kilgore
This edition of the Fleet Meets series features one of the industry's best leaders driving multi-market and national operations.
Read More →
Why Reactive Fleet Management Is Becoming Too Expensive to Sustain
Research highlights a growing need for proactive management strategies to address rising costs in fleet operations effectively.
Read More →
What Your Fleet KPIs Aren’t Telling You
Tracking fleet metrics is only useful when the data leads to better decisions. This guide helps fleet leaders assess cost, utilization, and downtime more accurately, identify performance gaps, and prioritize the actions that can improve operational results.
Read More →
Hidden in Plain Sight: Fleet Compliance Risks
Fleet compliance isn't just about having policies — it's about consistently enforcing them. This practical guide reveals six hidden compliance risks common in public sector and shared fleet operations and outlines proven strategies to improve visibility, accountability, and audit readiness
Read More →
Turning Fleet Payment Data into Executive Insights
Does data alone drive results in operations?
Read More →