Automotive Fleet
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Government Needs To Revamp Crash Tests To Deal With SUVs

WASHINGTON, D.C. — The government's crash test program for vehicles needs an upgrade to remain relevant as automobiles and safety risks change, congressional investigators said on April 28, according to a report by the Associated Press.

by Staff
May 3, 2005
3 min to read


WASHINGTON, D.C. — The government's crash test program for vehicles needs an upgrade to remain relevant as automobiles and safety risks change, congressional investigators said on April 28, according to a report by the Associated Press. The usefulness of the crash test program — which includes a star-rating system — has diminished with the growing popularity of SUVs and other light trucks, creating different safety risks not fully addressed by the tests, the Government Accountability Office said. "The program is at a crossroads where it will need to change to maintain its relevance," according to the report, which members of Congress requested. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) tests vehicles and rates them on a scale of one to five stars – five stars is the highest score – to help consumers judge an automobile's crashworthiness and likelihood of rolling over. NHTSA conducts its frontal-impact test at 35 mph, measuring the equivalent of two identical vehicles striking each other head-on. The side-impact test is conducted at 38.5 mph, and the rollover test simulates a driver steering sharply in one direction, then sharply in the other at speeds between 35 mph to 50 mph. The report said the tests need to better account for SUVs, which have been more susceptible to rollovers, and the damage caused when the popular vehicles strike passenger cars. Rollovers account for about 30 percent of fatalities. NHTSA's program, which began in 1978, could be improved by developing better ways of measuring how SUVs, large trucks, and pickups interact with small vehicles in crashes, how to protect occupants in rollovers, and by rating technologies that help reduce accidents, such as electronic stability control. The report also suggests stronger standards for roof crush, which has been criticized by safety groups as major problem in SUV rollovers, and the use of crash test dummies of different sizes. Current government tests use an average-size adult male. NHTSA administrator Jeffrey Runge said he had not yet reviewed the report but called the crash test program "a terrific value for the American consumer." The agency conducted 85 crash tests and 36 rollover tests in the 2004 budget year at a cost of $7.7 million. The agency is expected to release a new roof crush standard later this year and has sought input from the industry in improving the crash test program. Most vehicles receive four or five stars, the report found, making it difficult for consumers to compare safety value. It said the system gives automakers few incentives to improve vehicle safety. Auto industry officials said they conduct tests without prompting from the government and have implemented advanced safety technology in vehicles, including electronic stability control, and side-head protection airbags. Eron Shosteck, a spokesman for the Alliance of Automobile Manufacturers, said the rating system is "one piece of information that helps consumers decide on their next vehicle purchase, but it's also important to remember that automakers invest billions of dollars in safety research." Results of government crash tests are posted on www.SaferCar.gov/.

Topics:Operations

More Operations

Automotive Fleet graphic featuring the title “Reading the Global Signals: What AI and the Energy Transition Mean for Fleets Now” in bold white text against a dark navy-blue gradient background, with a thin cyan divider and the Automotive Fleet logo at the bottom.
Operations•November 11, 2026

Reading the Global Signals: What AI and the Energy Transition Mean for Fleets Now

How can fleet managers navigate a never-ending, changing industry landscape?

Read More →
Automotive Fleet News Recap thumbnail featuring a woman in a blue sleeveless top looking toward the headline, “90% Use Telematics. Are Fleets Getting Safer?” against a dark blue background with bold red accents.
Operations•by Faith Howell•November 6, 2026

90% Use Telematics. Are Fleets Getting Safer? | AF News Recap

This week, we're breaking down which industries have the highest rates, how Jamie McKay manages 2,400 vehicles, what's happening with the 2027 fleet awards, and why software-defined vehicles could introduce new costs.

Read More →
Collage of FFC2026 roundtables
Operations•by Chris Brown•November 5, 2026

What's Best Handled by an FMC, and What's Better Done Directly?

Fleet managers continue to rely on FMCs for essential services but are taking a closer look at where working directly with suppliers can improve efficiency and responsiveness.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Erin Gilchrist, inaugural Mike Antich Spirit of Fleet Award winner, featured in Automotive Fleet's Fleet Meets series, wearing a charcoal blazer against a white background.
Operations•by Faith Howell•November 5, 2026

Fleet Meets: Erin Gilchrist

Meet Erin Gilchrist, the inaugural Mike Antich Spirit of Fleet Award winner, as she shares insights on leadership, mentorship, the power of industry connections, and why people remain at the heart of fleet's future.

Read More →
Automotive Fleet video thumbnail featuring Jamie McKay alongside a male interviewer, with the headline “Jamie McKay Gives Fleet a Voice With Her Company’s Leadership” against a blue and black background.
Operations•by Chris Brown•November 4, 2026

How 2026 Fleet Visionary Jamie McKay Manages 2,400 Vehicles Across 37 States

How do you keep 2,400 vehicles running across 37 states? Fleet Visionary Award winner Jamie McKay shares how collaboration, flexibility, and a few simple strategies help her tackle fleet management challenges at Aptive Pest Control.

Read More →
Fleet operating costs for 2026 over image of a service center
Operations•by Chris Brown•November 1, 2026

Managing Fleet Costs in an Era of Permanent Volatility

Fleet operating costs have risen more than 20% since 2020, raising a key question: When does extending a vehicle's service life stop making financial sense?

Read More →
Ad Loading...
An Automotive Fleet podcast thumbnail
Operations•October 29, 2026

The Next Evolution of Fleet Management: Autonomous Operations

This opening keynote session at the Fleet Forward Conference highlights the future of autonomous driving for fleets.

Read More →
A picture of a transparent catalytic converter with blue text and the Automotive Fleet logo on the top.
Operations•October 29, 2026

How to Reduce the Total Cost of Risk From Catalytic Converter Theft

A stolen catalytic converter can cost fleets far more in downtime and lost productivity than in repairs. A total-cost-of-risk approach can help fleet managers quantify their exposure and prioritize theft prevention.

Read More →
AF news recap thumbnail
Operations•by Faith Howell•October 26, 2026

Personal-Use Charges Rise as Vehicle Values Fall | AF News Recap

Personal-use charges are climbing, wholesale used-vehicle values are declining, and commercial fleet sales growth is slowing. This week, we're breaking down the latest fleet data, plus how Element Fleet Management is helping Waymo prepare for its first Canadian robotaxi market.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A transparent blue background of a hand stamping a paper is the background of text that says "What about fleet policy exceptions?" with the Automotive Fleet logo in the bottom right corner.
Operations•by Faith Howell•October 20, 2026

Here's When You Should Make an Exception to Fleet Policy

Fleet policies are designed to create consistency, but not every driver or situation fits neatly within standard rules.

Read More →