Automotive Fleet
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

GM and Toyota Lead Vincentric '2012 Best Fleet Value' in America Awards

BINGHAM FARMS, MI - The brands with the highest number of winners across the different vehicle categories include General Motors, with nine vehicles, and Toyota, with seven vehicles, according to Vincentric.

by Staff
April 10, 2012
3 min to read


BINGHAM FARMS, MI – Vincentric announced its “Best Fleet Value in America” awards for the 2012 model-year. The brands with the highest number of winners across the different vehicle categories include General Motors, with nine vehicles, and Toyota, with seven vehicles. A number of other brands earned multiple awards as well, including Ford, Hyundai, Chrysler Group, Volvo, and BMW.

Vincentric analyzed more than 2,700 vehicle configurations in 20 different lifecycle scenarios. The company used eight different cost-related variables, including depreciation, fees and taxes, financing, fuel, insurance, maintenance, opportunity cost, and repairs, in its evaluation of each model. The company said it measured lifecycle costs in all 50 U.S. states, plus DC.

“By taking into account a wide range of lifecycle scenarios using all ownership costs, our awards enable organizations to understand and evaluate the best vehicles for their fleet," stated David Wurster, President of Vincentric. "Fleet operators, fleet management and leasing companies, and fleet dealers can all benefit from utilizing comprehensive and dynamic cost-of-ownership data to make informed vehicle choices."

For the specific brands, Vincentric said General Motors did well in the van and heavy-duty pickup segments, and Toyota earned awards based on having a “well-balanced line-up” in the passenger vehicle and crossover categories, including winning in three out of four hybrid segments.

The Mercedes-Benz Sprinter won in three of the heavy-duty van segments. Ford won in 1/2-ton pickup segment, with its 2012-MY Ford F-150. Chrysler and Hyundai each had three winners. Hyundai won in the mid-size sedan segment with its Sonata.  

You can see the full list of winners below. Visit Vincentric’s website for its evaluation of each vehicle.

Ad Loading...

Passenger Cars

  • Hyundai Accent GLS Sedan (Subcompact)

  • Hyundai Elantra Touring GLS Hatchback (Compact, Hatchback)

  • Nissan Versa S (Compact, Sedan)

  • Toyota Prius 4D Hatchback (Compact, Hybrid)

  • Mercedes-Benz C Class C250 (Compact, Premium)

  • Hyundai Sonata GLS 2.4 (Mid-Size Sedan)

  • Buick Regal 2.4L eAssist (Mid-Size Sedan, Premium)

  • Toyota Camry Hybrid LE (Mid-Size Sedan, Hybrid)

  • Toyota Prius Plug-in Hybrid (Plug-in Hybrid)

  • Ford Taurus SE (Large)

  • Audi A6 3.2 Premium CVT FrontTrak (Large, Premium)

  • BMW 7-Series 750i (Prestige, Sedan)

  • Subaru Impreza Base (Wagon)

  • Volvo XC70 3.2 FWD (Wagon, Premium)

Sport Utilities and Crossovers

  • Jeep Patriot Sport 2WD (Crossover, Compact, Entry-Level)

  • Toyota RAV4 Base (Crossover, Compact, Mid-Level)

  • Volvo XC60 3.2 FWD (Crossover, Compact, Premium)

  • Dodge Journey SE FWD (Crossover, Mid-Size)

  • BMW X5 Xdrive 35i (Crossover, Mid-Size, Premium)

  • Mazda CX-9 Sport FWD (Crossover, Large)

  • Buick Enclave Base (Crossover, Large, Premium)

  • Ford Escape Hybrid FWD (Crossover, Hybrid)

  • Toyota FJ Cruiser 2WD (SUV, Compact)

  • Toyota 4Runner SR5 V6 (SUV, Mid Size)

  • Chevrolet Tahoe LS Commercial 2WD (SUV, Large)

  • Mercedes-Benz GL350 CDI (SUV, Premium)

  • Chevrolet Avalanche LS 2WD (Sport Utility Truck)

Pickup Trucks

  • Toyota Tacoma Base Double Cab 2WD (Compact Pickup)

  • Ford F-150 XL Reg Cab 2WD 126 (Full-Size Pickup, 1/2 Ton)

  • Chevrolet/GMC Silverado/Sierra 2500HD LT Reg Cab 2WD (Full-Size Pickup, Heavy Duty 3/4 Ton)

  • Chevrolet/GMC Silverado/Sierra 3500HD LT Reg Cab 2WD SRW (Full-Size Pickup, Heavy Duty, 1 Ton)

Vans

  • Dodge Grand Caravan SE FWD (Minivan)

  • Ford Transit Connect XL (Mini Cargo Van)

  • Chevrolet/GMC Express/Savana G1500 SWB (Full-Size Passenger Van, 1/2 Ton)

  • Mercedes-Benz Sprinter Wagon 2500 Std Roof 144 WB (Full-Size Passenger Van, 3/4 Ton)

  • Chevrolet/GMC Express/Savana G3500 Wagon LWB (Full-Size Passenger Van, 1 Ton)

  • Chevrolet/GMC Express/Savana G1500 Cargo SWB (Full-Size Cargo Van, 1/2 Ton)

  • Mercedes-Benz Sprinter Van 2500 Std Roof 144 WB (Full-Size Cargo Van, 3/4 Ton)

  • Mercedes-Benz Sprinter Van 3500 High Roff 144 WB (Full-Size Cargo Van, 1 Ton)

More Operations

A blue Automotive Fleet graphic representing the weekly AF News Recap series.
Operationsby Faith HowellMay 4, 2026

From Waffle House to AI: Fleet Trends You Need to Know

In this AF news recap, host Faith Howell covers how Waffle House stepped up during disaster response and new AI tech on the market.

Read More →
OperationsApril 30, 2026

Fleet Operations in the Age of AI: Navigating Ethical and Legal Challenges

AI is no longer a future concept for fleets—it’s already embedded in the tools, data, and decisions that operators rely on every day. In this episode of the Fleet Forward Podcast, recorded live at Fleet Forward, industry leaders take the conversation beyond hype to examine what responsible AI adoption really looks like in fleet operations.

Read More →
OperationsApril 30, 2026

Factory Installed vs. Aftermarket: Choosing the Right Telematics Path & Managing the Data

As fleets rethink how they capture, manage, and act on vehicle data, telematics is at a major inflection point. In this episode of the Fleet Forward Podcast, we dive deep into one of the most pressing questions facing fleet leaders today: Should you rely on OEM factory-installed connectivity, aftermarket devices, or a hybrid of both?

Read More →
Ad Loading...
OperationsApril 30, 2026

What Real-Time Data Reveals About EV Cost, Performance, and Scalability

Experts from telematics analytics, fleet-as-a-service operations, and national EV benchmarking share how real-time data is reshaping fleet strategy—dispelling assumptions, validating best practices, and exposing costly missteps.

Read More →
OperationsApril 30, 2026

Planning Through Policy Shifts: What Fleets Must Track in 2026

A powerhouse panel featuring experts from the American Automotive Leasing Association, CalSTART, and municipal fleet leadership dives into the realities of navigating shifting emissions rules, regulatory waivers, federal agency actions, the future of the EPA’s endangerment finding, and the push for unified standards. They also examine the impacts of tariffs, autonomous vehicle policy, battery innovation, and the accelerating global EV market.

Read More →
OperationsApril 30, 2026

Managing Market Turbulence with Strategic Fleet Insights

This episode kicks off with a deep dive into the technologies and market forces reshaping today’s fleet landscape. Host Chris Brown is joined by Laolu Adeola (Leke Services), Tyson Jomini (J.D. Power), and Richard Hall (ZappiRide) to break down real-world data, shifting incentives, and practical strategies fleet leaders can use right now.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Clipboards with flooded cars in background.
Disaster Responseby Chris BrownApril 30, 2026

Adapting Fleet Policy When Disasters Strike

In the middle of natural disasters fleet managers must shift priorities to protect people and assets. What policy items should be loosened, and when should the line be held?

Read More →
OperationsApril 24, 2026

EV Reality Check: How Fleets Are Managing Policy Shifts, Safety, and Scaling Challenges

In this episode, fleet leaders from municipal, university, and private-sector organizations share a candid EV reality check. From infrastructure setbacks and policy whiplash to grant funding, total cost of ownership, and charging resiliency, this conversation dives into what it actually takes to scale electrification in the real world.

Read More →
2019 Automotive Fleet Hall of Fame inductees Joe LaRosa Bob Miesen Bud Morrison Theresa Ragozine portraits
Operationsby StaffApril 21, 2026

Fleet Hall of Fame Honorees Through the Years

A running list of the fleet industry’s most influential leaders, recognized for their lasting impact on commercial fleet management.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Operationsby Chris BrownApril 20, 2026

2026 Salary Survey: Six-Figure Fleet Manager Salaries Become the Norm

After a decade of lagging compensation, fleet manager pay is climbing. But expanding responsibilities, larger fleets, and growing complexity continue to redefine the role.

Read More →