Automotive Fleet
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

You May Be Violating Federal Law When Using Motor Vehicle Records in Hiring Decisions

You may be breaking federal law if you are ordering motor vehicle record (MVR) checks through a third-party reporting agency and not following procedures specified by the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA).

Mike Antich
Mike AntichFormer Editor and Associate Publisher
Read Mike's Posts
January 1, 2001
You May Be Violating Federal Law When Using Motor Vehicle Records in Hiring Decisions

 

4 min to read


This warning was made at the CEI Fleet Customer Advisory Council meeting last September by Luanne Peterpaul, an attorney and partner of the law firm Peterpaul, Clark & Corcoran in Springfield, NJ, which specializes in labor law. "The name Fair Credit Reporting Act is a misnomer because it covers not only credit reports, but all consumer and investigative reports conducted by third parties, including motor vehicle reports," said Peterpaul. Before going furthur, it is important to state that background checks, such as MVRs, which are done by your own staff as part of their regular responsibilities, are not covered by the FCRA. Employers are required to comply with the FCRA when they are using a "consumer reporting agency" to perform credit and background checks on their current or prospective employees. According to Peterpaul, the FCRA definition for a "consumer reporting agency" is so broad that it would include fleet services companies that provide MVRs as a third-party service. What brought this about were amendments to the FCRA, which went into effect on Oct. 1, 1997. Known as the Consumer Credit Reporting Reform Act, it imposes the following responsibilities and duties on employers who use reports supplied by third-party reporting agencies. Before requesting a consumer report (which includes MVRs), employers must: 1. Make a clear and conspicuous disclosure to the applicant or employee that a report may be requested. 2. Obtain written permission from the applicant or employee before obtaining or ordering a consumer report pertaining to that individual. "Furthermore, a consumer reporting agency (such as a fleet services company) may not furnish a consumer report to an employer until the employer certifies that it has given the required notice and received written authorization from the employee or applicant to obtain the report," added Peterpaul. "The employer also must certify that it will comply with the FCRA's requirements if it subsequently uses information from the consumer report to take adverse action with respect to the employee or applicant." The amendments also require that before taking any "adverse action" based in whole or in part on the consumer report, the employer must provide the employee or applicant an actual copy of the report and a written summary of the consumer's rights as prescribed by the Federal Trade Commission (FTC). "Adverse action" is defined to include "a denial of employment or any other decision for employment purposes that adversely affects any current or prospective employee," said Peterpaul. In the event an employer negligently or willfully fails to comply with the FCRA, that employer shall be liable to the applicant or employee for actual damages, costs, and reasonable attorney's fees. Actual damages for willful non-compliance are limited to an amount not less than $100 and not more than $1,000. There is no set limit on punitive damages. The FTC can sue violators for up to $2,500 per violation for injunctive relief, according to Riker Danzig, a New Jersey law firm that has published a paper on this issue. Employers should also be aware that there are restrictions on the type of information that can be supplied by a consumer reporting agency. According to Riker Danzig, the FCRA specifies that no consumer reporting agency may make a consumer report containing information about "records of arrest, indictment, or conviction of crime (such as a drunk driving conviction) which, from the date of disposition, release or parole, antedate the report by more than seven years." However, these limitations do not apply to searches performed on individuals whose annual salaries are expected to exceed $75,000, which could exempt many sales representatives, who are assigned company vehicles. If you are using a third party to order MVRs on your current or prospective employees, there are four rules you need to follow: 1. Employers must provide a written disclosure. 2. Obtain written permission from applicants and employees before obtaining MVRs from a third-party reporting agency. 3. Refrain from using any information contained in an MVR in violation of any federal or state equal employment opportunity law or regulation. 4. Employers must provide copies of the reports to employees, along with a summary of the consumer's rights, before taking any adverse employment action based on the report. In addition to the federal requirements, many states are enacting their own statutes regarding MVRs. It is in every fleet manager's best interest to become familiar with the requirements of the Consumer Credit Reporting Reform Act, which amends the FCRA, along with state statutes governing MVRs. Let me know what you think.

Topics:Operations
Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Operations

Handshake graphic featuring BBL Fleet and Velcor Leasing Corporation logos announcing BBL Fleet’s acquisition of Velcor to expand fleet management services nationwide.
Operationsby News/Media ReleaseMay 8, 2026

BBL Fleet Acquires Velcor Leasing Corporation

BBL Fleet expanded its footprint in the fleet management industry with the acquisition of Velcor Leasing Corporation of Madison through a stock purchase agreement finalized Feb. 27, 2026.

Read More →
Graphic reading “What’s New From Lytx at Protect 2026?” over a blue digital network background highlighting Lytx fleet technology and AI-powered safety solutions.
Operationsby News/Media ReleaseMay 6, 2026

Lytx Introduces New AI Fleet Technologies at Protect 2026

The company introduced new AI-driven fleet safety and operations technologies during its annual user conference.

Read More →
Cover image for the “5th Annual Market Pulse Report” by Element titled “Navigating fleet management in 2026: Data and insights shaping the future of fleet and mobility.” The design features an aerial view of a cable-stayed bridge with vehicles traveling on a highway beside a dense green forest. A teal graphic panel overlays the lower portion of the image, with the Element logo and tagline “Intelligence in motion” at the bottom.
SponsoredMay 6, 2026

Fleet Costs Are Rising: Here’s How Leaders Are Responding

Fleet leaders are under pressure to reduce costs, adapt to economic uncertainty, and make smarter decisions. See how peers across North America are responding with real data, proven strategies, and forward-looking insights. Download the 2026 Market Pulse Report to benchmark your strategy and uncover where you can gain an edge.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A blue Automotive Fleet graphic representing the weekly AF News Recap series.
Operationsby Faith HowellMay 4, 2026

From Waffle House to AI: Fleet Trends You Need to Know

In this AF news recap, host Faith Howell covers how Waffle House stepped up during disaster response and new AI tech on the market.

Read More →
OperationsApril 30, 2026

Fleet Operations in the Age of AI: Navigating Ethical and Legal Challenges

AI is no longer a future concept for fleets—it’s already embedded in the tools, data, and decisions that operators rely on every day. In this episode of the Fleet Forward Podcast, recorded live at Fleet Forward, industry leaders take the conversation beyond hype to examine what responsible AI adoption really looks like in fleet operations.

Read More →
OperationsApril 30, 2026

Factory Installed vs. Aftermarket: Choosing the Right Telematics Path & Managing the Data

As fleets rethink how they capture, manage, and act on vehicle data, telematics is at a major inflection point. In this episode of the Fleet Forward Podcast, we dive deep into one of the most pressing questions facing fleet leaders today: Should you rely on OEM factory-installed connectivity, aftermarket devices, or a hybrid of both?

Read More →
Ad Loading...
OperationsApril 30, 2026

What Real-Time Data Reveals About EV Cost, Performance, and Scalability

Experts from telematics analytics, fleet-as-a-service operations, and national EV benchmarking share how real-time data is reshaping fleet strategy—dispelling assumptions, validating best practices, and exposing costly missteps.

Read More →
OperationsApril 30, 2026

Planning Through Policy Shifts: What Fleets Must Track in 2026

A powerhouse panel featuring experts from the American Automotive Leasing Association, CalSTART, and municipal fleet leadership dives into the realities of navigating shifting emissions rules, regulatory waivers, federal agency actions, the future of the EPA’s endangerment finding, and the push for unified standards. They also examine the impacts of tariffs, autonomous vehicle policy, battery innovation, and the accelerating global EV market.

Read More →
OperationsApril 30, 2026

Managing Market Turbulence with Strategic Fleet Insights

This episode kicks off with a deep dive into the technologies and market forces reshaping today’s fleet landscape. Host Chris Brown is joined by Laolu Adeola (Leke Services), Tyson Jomini (J.D. Power), and Richard Hall (ZappiRide) to break down real-world data, shifting incentives, and practical strategies fleet leaders can use right now.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Clipboards with flooded cars in background.
Disaster Responseby Chris BrownApril 30, 2026

Adapting Fleet Policy When Disasters Strike

In the middle of natural disasters fleet managers must shift priorities to protect people and assets. What policy items should be loosened, and when should the line be held?

Read More →