Automotive Fleet
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Ford and General Motors Fleet Price Fixing Indictment Details

Federal government charges automakers with conspiracy to end special buyer discounts.

by AF Staff
January 1, 1973
6 min to read


The particulars of the federal government's fleet discount price fixing case against General Motors and Ford have been disclosed in a 268-page document following a federal district judge's denial of a defense motion to suppress details.

The original indictment, handed down last May, charges the auto makers with a conspiracy to end special fleet buyer discounts. The government contends that GM and Ford conducted a three-year campaign with the National Automobile Dealers Association (NADA) and Peterson, Howell& Heather, Inc. (PH & H) of Baltimore, often termed the nation's leading automotive leasing company, in an attempt to urge Chrysler Corporation to go along with the discount-ending effort.

Ad Loading...

Pressure to end the discounts some say, came instead from the car dealers themselves, according to reports. GM and Ford, they say, eliminated their discounts to fleet customers in response to pressure from their own dealers, but Chrysler would not follow suit. Many Dealers have long been vocal in their contention that fleet buyers could ob­tain better prices from manufacturers than dealers themselves could.

The May anti-trust charges were brought only against Ford and GM, but PH&H and the NADA and an extensive listing of top automotive industry officials also were named as co-conspirators in the case.

The government claims that in 1962 Ford and GM had 84 percent of the fleet market, while Chrysler held about10 percent. These figures coincided with the percentages each of them maintained in the entire automobile market­place. Chrysler started offering fleet discounts in the early60's, the government claims, and by 1967, attained 24 percent of the fleet and leasing market, mainly at General Motor's expense.

The government's case maintains that Ford and GM began cutting their fleet and lease customer prices in 1968 to regain market percentages lost to Chrysler. With the knowledge that these two companies wanted the discounts eliminated, the NADA began an extensive campaign to help abolish them. But Chrysler refused to go along, according to the government's bill of particulars.

PH&H, it says, also had been pressing for fleet discount elimination and William Fraser, a PH&H executive acted as a mediator between Ford and GM. And in May, 1970, state and local governments began losing GM and Ford discounts through NADA pressure, the federal government contends.

Ad Loading...

In 1971, private fleet buyers' discounts were done away with for that year's Ford and GM cars, according to the government.

Previously, in July, 1970, two Chrysler dealers filed an antitrust suit against Chrysler, seeking triple damages for the use of fleet subsidies from 1963 to 1970. The dealers also filed a significant injunction against further use of such subsidies. And the NADA supported the dealers in their" case, according to the government position, as part of its campaign to eliminate the discounts.

The charges allege that just before Ford and GM stopped issuing fleet discounts, Chrysler President John J. Riccardo refused further negotiations with NADA.

GM did not intend to suppress evidence by asking that the bill of particulars not be made public, according to Ross L. Malone, GM vice president and general counsel but the company did want to defer public release of the government's contentions until a trial could be held and the auto company refutes the charges.

Ford sought to protect from injury and embarrassment the large number of persons who were not named by the grand jury and who otherwise may not have been involved in any trial, according to Wright Tisdale, Ford vice president and general counsel.

Ad Loading...

The suit also charges that the auto makers passed confidential information among themselves and laid the groundwork for mutual assistance pacts in the event of a strike against any one of them. Such mutual assistance pacts are not legal, the government says, but they were not the cause for the indictments.

If GM and Ford are convicted of the charges against them in the indictments, the auto companies could be fined up to $100,000.

A bill of particulars is not evidence but lists the contentions of government lawyers explaining their understanding of the case. During a trial the court may or may not admit into evidence what the government has listed in its bill of particulars. Also, during trial the government is limited to consideration of matters contained in the bill only.

GM and Ford already have entered pleas of not guilty to the charges. And in the months before the case goes to trial next September, the defendants may enter guilty pleas to lesser charges or the government may dismiss the suit. In 1972, 10.9 million cars and 2.6 million trucks were sold. More than one million were purchased by companies on a fleet basis, as part of a growth trend that has enabled fleet sales to rise 50 percent in the past seven years.

As the fleet market grew, there was strong competition for sales, which often were in 100 to 1,000-car lots, and manufacturers began offering discounts.

Ad Loading...

Some dealers complained that fleet sales arranged between the fleet buyer and auto manufacturer were cutting into dealership business. By 1969, fleet sales totals included more than 10 percent of new car registrations, and some thought they would account for 20 to 30 percent of the auto business by the mid-1970s unless something was done.

Chrysler does proportionately better in the fleet business than the company does in straight dealer sales. Its market share of the fleet business was 24.3 percent in 1972, about 50 percent more than its overall share of total domestic car sales. The company had 19.9 percent of the fleet market in1965.

The increase in the overall fleet business from less than 700, 000 cars in 1965 to more than one million last year has been attributed to the automotive leasing business. Fleet sales to leasing companies have almost doubled in the last seven years, as did sales to rental fleets.

On the other hand, sales to companies which use vehicles for their business and sales to governmental units showed only modest gains. Figures for the first 10 months last year show 783,668 fleet car sales, compared with about 819,000the previous year, indicating a slight dip in fleet car sales. In the government's case against Ford and GM, sales to leasing, rental, commercial and governmental customers all are considered fleet car sales.

Amid the twelve volumes of exhibits are included a large number of documents, stockholder reports, handwritten notes, calendars, market studies, speeches, news stories and internal corporate communications scaling some 70 pounds.

Ad Loading...

Tom Kleene of the Detroit Free Press analyzed some of the cost figures and reports that during the 1970 model year GM's costs for allowances to its fleet purchase accounts were estimated at $60 million in addition to another $10 million for monies indirectly supporting the programs.

The programs ranged from the basic discounts from the initial purchase price of the vehicle to the now defunct buy-back plans at the expiration of the lease on a unit.

In spite of fleet sales volume increasing from 407,000 in 1969 to 450,000 in 1970 estimates of program costs in­creased from $123 to $133 per unit.

As AF had pointed out editorially in June of 1972, a good deal of confusion and diversity of opinion still exists on fleet discounts even within the industry. Volume purchasing can stir an industry where true competition exists.


Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Operations

Two employees pull opposite ends of a rope in a tug-of-war, illustrating workplace conflict and the leadership strategies fleet organizations use to improve communication and teamwork.
Operationsby Faith HowellJune 8, 2026

How to Manage Conflict for Your Fleet Operations

Conflict management is becoming a core leadership skill. Here are five strategies fleet leaders should know.

Read More →
wheel geotab image
SponsoredJune 1, 2026

Turning Connected Vehicle Data Into Decisions That Matter

Fleet leaders have more data than ever, but turning that data into clear, actionable decisions remains a challenge. This white paper shows how leading organizations are using connected vehicle data to improve safety, reduce costs, and optimize fleet performance. Learn how to turn insight into action across your fleet.

Read More →
A person holding a clipboard and writing on an inspection checklist beside the wheel of a large white vehicle, likely conducting a fleet or safety inspection.
SponsoredJune 1, 2026

Cameras, Safety and Insurance: From Reactive Claims to Real-time Prevention

Commercial auto remains one of the most challenging and costly lines of coverage for fleet operators and insurers alike. Learn more about how to effectively address these issues from Onur Aksan, Enterprise Business Development Executive, Geotab.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
fleetio coast pay
SponsoredMay 29, 2026

Are You Tracking Your Fleet's True Total Cost of Ownership?

Bobit Business Media surveyed 190 fleet professionals and found that while most fleets are tracking costs, fragmented systems and data gaps are keeping true TCO visibility out of reach. With rising pressure to control spend in an increasingly volatile environment, the gap between what fleets think they know and what the data actually shows is wider than you might expect. See how your peers are managing costs today and where the industry still has room to improve.

Read More →
Promotional graphic for a fleet management whitepaper titled “From Data Overload to Decisive Action: 5 Steps to Drive Smarter Fleet Decisions.” The design features a row of white commercial fleet vans, blue and lime-green branding, and supporting text about using telematics data to improve fleet performance, driver behavior, safety, and operational decision-making. A highlighted quote reads, “The challenge is no longer collecting data. The challenge is using it effectively.” The Utilimarc logo appears at the bottom alongside the website URL.
SponsoredMay 28, 2026

Turn Fleet Data Into Smarter Decisions

Fleet leaders have access to more operational data than ever, but disconnected systems and unclear metrics often slow decision-making instead of improving it. This article outlines five practical steps fleets can take to transform fragmented data into actionable insights that improve planning, safety, utilization, and long-term performance.

Read More →
SponsoredMay 15, 2026

Hybrids: Electrification Without the Challenges

For fleet managers, fuel is one of the biggest line items in the budget — and it's one hybrids can shrink without changing how your people work. Download the eBook to see the numbers, understand the technology, and get a step-by-step guide to making the switch.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Man speaking during an Automotive Fleet interview beside text reading “The 60% Driver Improvement Nobody Expected!” with blue motion graphics background.
Operationsby Chris BrownMay 14, 2026

How NOV Uses Telematics to Improve Fleet Safety Across 160 Locations

James Victory of NOV discusses how the company manages fleet safety, maintenance, and telematics across more than 150 locations supporting oilfield operations throughout the U.S.

Read More →
A graphic with Ford Pro's Steven Sanstostasi's headshot on it representing the Fleet Meets series.
Operationsby Faith HowellMay 14, 2026

Fleet Meets: Steven Santostasi

This edition of the Fleet Meets series features Steven Santostasi, the current TSP channel manager for Ford Pro.

Read More →
Cover of a whitepaper titled “The Hidden Costs of Departmentally Assigned Vehicles on Your Fleet” featuring a black fleet vehicle driving on a road at sunset. Subheadline reads: “Discover how your fleet can reduce costs and minimize risk by implementing vehicle sharing.” The document focuses on fleet optimization, vehicle sharing, cost reduction, utilization tracking, and risk management for fleet operations.
SponsoredMay 13, 2026

Why Fleet Managers Are Replacing Departmental Vehicles with Shared Motor Pools

Departmentally assigned vehicles often create hidden costs through underutilization, poor visibility, and increased administrative burden. This white paper explores how shared motor pool strategies help fleets reduce costs, improve accountability, and optimize vehicle utilization.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Three team members in shop with Chris
Operationsby Chris BrownMay 12, 2026

Soap Box Derby Challenge: Assembling the Crew

Meet Gabriel, Matthew, and Angel — the team helping bring this soap box derby build to life.

Read More →