Automotive Fleet
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

U.S. Indicts 11 in Brooklyn Chop Shop Worth Millions

Federal prosecutors have indicted 11 men in a $20 million operation that for 16 years turned wrecked cars into a real estate empire inside a Brooklyn industrial building, according to the New York Times newspaper.

by Staff
September 15, 2004
3 min to read


Federal prosecutors have indicted 11 men in a $20 million operation that for 16 years turned wrecked cars into a real estate empire inside a Brooklyn industrial building, according to the New York Times newspaper. With the money earned from selling stolen cars and fixed-up wrecks, those who ran the operation bought minimalls, apartment buildings, and shopping centers on Long Island, prosecutors said. Their empire also included a mansion in the wealthy Nassau County village of Upper Brookville. In the indictment, unsealed yesterday, prosecutors said the chop shop, which was shut down last year, had operated since 1987 under the name Astra Motor Cars, an auto salvage yard in Greenpoint. According to court papers, the operation's strengths were stealing cars, transferring new vehicle identification numbers onto the cars, and then reselling them to unwitting consumers. But in a telephone interview, Gary Brown, an assistant United States attorney, said the shop's clientele also included drug dealers, who rented cars with hollow com-partments for up to $30,000 per day. The shop's co-owners, Michael Pescatore and Sanford Edmonston, pleaded not guilty at their arraignments yesterday in Federal District Court in Central Islip to a number of charges, including mail fraud and money laundering. Prosecutors said the other nine men were employees of the shop. Pescatore was released on $3 million bail, but Edmonston was ordered held without bail after prosecutors told a judge that he had threatened to "take care" of a witness, Brown said. Martin Adelman, a lawyer for Pescatore, declined to comment on the charges yesterday. Neither Edmon-ston nor his lawyer could be reached for comment. Once, Brown said, Edmonston sold one of the cars with hollow compartments to Albanian drug dealers, but not before equipping it with a global tracking device. Edmonston followed its movements, and one day, he stole 30 kilograms of cocaine from the car, Brown said. The 18-month investigation that culminated in the indictment began when Suffolk County investigators tracking down insurance fraud cases talked with two car thieves who led them to Astra Motor Cars, prosecu-tors said. Prosecutors searched and shut down the business in June 2003, and its license to operate was revoked in June, Suffolk County prosecutors said. Edmonston, the company's general manager, and Pescatore, its presi-dent, were arrested last year on similar state charges, and are now awaiting trial. The federal indictment says the men bought wrecked cars in Florida, rebuilt them with stolen parts, and sold them in New York after bribing an employee of the Ohio Department of Motor Vehicles to issue new titles for damaged cars. According to the indictment, the defendants sometimes stole a car, stripped its usable parts and left its body on the side of a road. Later, the defendants bought the same discarded frame at a public auction, rebuilt the car and sold it. They also sold cars to deceased or fictional buyers to put the title into someone else's name, thereby insulating the company from culpability, the indictment says.

More Remarketing

Series of colored line graphs showing the recent history of average used listing prices.
Remarketingby News/Media ReleaseJune 12, 2026

Used Vehicle Prices Climb Higher As Sales Pace Slows

The higher prices at used retail reflect strong wholesale values earlier in the spring, particularly for older, more affordable vehicles.

Read More →
Dark blue bar graphs showing percentage gains in average wholesale used vehicle prices
Remarketingby News/Media ReleaseJune 5, 2026

Wholesale Used Vehicle Market Sustains Moderate Rise In Values, Prices

Trends continue to normalize after a strong start to the year, as consumers contend with higher gas prices in the coming summer months.

Read More →
Green and black bar graphs show May 2025 v. 2026 fleet vehicle sales into commercial, rental, and government fleet sectors.
Vehicle Researchby Martin RomjueJune 3, 2026

Commercial Fleet Sales Still Lead Sectors Despite May Mini Dip

The U.S. economy's continued growth and positive business investment are creating a favorable environment for fleet vehicle demand.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Pickup trucks in a row with overlay "Hidden Vehicle Value"
Remarketingby Chris BrownMay 18, 2026

How Connected Vehicle Data Is Lifting Fleet Resale Values

A vehicle health score could improve the value of fleet vehicles at remarketing. The path to a universal standard is forming, and fleets that understand the process early will be better positioned when it arrives.

Read More →
Blue bar graphs showing wholesale used vehicle price shifts according to vehicle segment.
Remarketingby News/Media ReleaseMay 11, 2026

Wholesale Used Vehicle Prices Slightly Up In April

The Iranian conflict and rising gas prices inject much uncertainty into the future wholesale used vehicle markets, as higher gas prices soak up spendable income from vehicle buyers.

Read More →
James McKinley stands on the stage during the 2026 CAR Conference and speaks about his acceptance of the Value Champion of the Year Award.
Remarketingby Chris BrownMay 8, 2026

CAR2026: James McKinley Wins Value Champion of the Year

James McKinley of City Rent a Truck was named the inaugural Fleet Value Champion at the CAR Conference for his data-driven approach to fleet lifecycle management and vehicle remarketing.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Eric Autenrieth accepts the Fleet Remarketer of the Year award on a stage at the CAR Conference in Cleveland, OH.
Remarketingby StaffMay 8, 2026

CAR2026: Eric Autenrieth Wins Remarketer of the Year

Eric Autenrieth was recognized at this year's CAR Conference as the Remarketer of the Year.

Read More →
Lawrence Knapp stands on stage as he hives his acceptance speech for the cosigner of the year award.
Remarketingby StaffMay 7, 2026

CAR2026: Lawrence Knapp Wins Consignor of the Year

Lawrence Knapp won the Cosigner of the Year award at this year's CAR Conference.

Read More →
Image of three award winners at 2026 CAR
Remarketingby Faith HowellMay 6, 2026

2026 CAR Awards Celebrate Industry Excellence

CAR’s annual Fleet Remarketing Awards opened a reimagined 2026 conference designed to bridge the worlds of fleet management and automotive remarketing.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Chris Brown standing on stage at The Conference of Automotive Remarketing announcing this year's award winners.
Remarketingby StaffMay 5, 2026

Inside the CAR2026 Awards: Leaders, Legacy & What’s Next

Here's a look inside the awards ceremony at the CAR Conference, where industry leaders reflected on the growth, impact, and future of automotive remarketing.

Read More →