Automotive Fleet
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Maintenance Costs: How High Is Too High?

Every fleet manager's boss has said, "Our maintenance costs are too high." Just what does "too high" mean? What are reasonable maintenance and repair costs?

by Al Willis
March 1, 1993
2 min to read


Every fleet manager's boss has said, "Our maintenance costs are too high." Just what does "too high" mean? What are reasonable maintenance and repair costs?

If you tried to compare your costs to other companies' costs, an apple-to-apple comparison might be difficult. Industries, policies, and fleets differ considerably in cost, and so do their recordkeeping methods. Therefore, you should compare your own fleet locations with each other or your own driver records within the separate locations.

Ad Loading...

Possibly, you already know what you are spending per location, but it would be wise to cumulatively determine what each fleet location is spending for a few important maintenance/repair categories such as:

  1. Engine.

  2. Transmission.

  3. Brakes.

  4. Tires and tire repairs.

  5. Collision costs not recovered.

  6. Preventive maintenance.

  7. All other.


How can this be accomplished? One way is to use the services of a fleet management company, which might cost $6 per month per vehicle. If you have 500 vehicles, maybe you don't want to spend $36,000 a year.

To achieve the same results in-house, you can do the following:

  • Have your branches code each cost item on an invoice by maintenance/repair category and vehicle number. For example, 1 = Engine, 2 = Transmission, and so forth. If one invoice includes both tire and preventive maintenance costs, show the dollar cost for each and code the expense to the appropriate category.

  • Require each driver to send a monthly odometer reading. Keep cumulative mileage records by location.

Ad Loading...

Once you have these monthly figures, it is a simple matter of calculating cumulating cost per mile for each category of cost. You can then compare locations and give facts to the managers or regional managers of the locations involved. Then, if one fleet location has a horrible record compared to the average fleet, it will be apparent. Only then can the local manager say, "Our maintenance costs are too high."

This article was written by Al Willis, retired fleet manager for Sammons Communications in Dallas, TX.



Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Operations

Cover of the AgileFleet white paper "Hidden in Plain Sight: Fleet Compliance Risks" with the AgileFleet logo and a photo of fleet vehicles parked outside a government building.
SponsoredAugust 7, 2026

Hidden in Plain Sight: Fleet Compliance Risks

Fleet compliance isn't just about having policies — it's about consistently enforcing them. This practical guide reveals six hidden compliance risks common in public sector and shared fleet operations and outlines proven strategies to improve visibility, accountability, and audit readiness

Read More →
Turning Fleet Payment data into executive insights blue podcast thumbnail
OperationsAugust 5, 2026

Turning Fleet Payment Data into Executive Insights

Does data alone drive results in operations?

Read More →
Graphic promoting Automotive Fleet's 2026 Personal Use Survey with the text "Have a Personal Use Policy? We Want to Know!" encouraging fleet managers to complete the annual industry survey.
Operationsby StaffAugust 5, 2026

Automotive Fleet Opens 2026 Personal Use Survey for Commercial Fleet Managers

Commercial and corporate fleet managers are invited to share how their organizations handle company vehicle personal-use policies, charges, and driver eligibility.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Gary Van Orden Retirement
Operationsby Jeanny AbrahamJuly 31, 2026

Gary Van Orden Retires After Nearly Four Decades in Commercial Fleet

From answering customer calls at Ford Motor Company to leading fleet sales across multiple OEMs and a fleet management company, Gary Van Orden's career reflects nearly four decades of leadership in commercial fleet.

Read More →
an Automotive Fleet podcast thumbnail
OperationsJuly 31, 2026

How Stellantis Plans to Get Ahead of Fleet Downtime

Vehicle acquisition may grab the headlines, but fleet uptime increasingly determines operating success. Darren Bradshaw of ‪Mopar‬ North America gives the details.

Read More →
A lineup of Hyundai vehicles with overlay text announcing the 2027 Commercial Fleet Program, highlighting new fleet incentives for eligible commercial and government buyers.
Operationsby News/Media ReleaseJuly 31, 2026

Hyundai Releases 2027 Commercial Program Incentives 

The 2027 Model Year "Fleet Street Incentives" are available to commercial and government fleets.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Chris Brown of Automotive Fleet and Lauren Fletcher of Work Truck pose beside a Soap Box Derby car in a Team Brown vs. Team Fletcher race graphic benefiting The Hourglass Foundation.
Operationsby News/Media ReleaseJuly 30, 2026

It's All Downhill from Here! Fleet Industry Raises $22,000 for Skilled Trades Scholarships

Work Truck’s Lauren Fletcher and Automotive Fleet’s Chris Brown turned a friendly racing rivalry into $22,000 for automotive technology and skilled trades scholarships.

Read More →
Commercial Fleet
SponsoredJuly 23, 2026

The Top 300 Commercial Fleets

The Top 300 Commercial Fleets: See the List

Read More →
Cover of the "Top 50 Green Fleets" report presented by Automotive Fleet and Inspiration Fleet, featuring an aerial nighttime photo of a lit highway interchange with looping ramps.
SponsoredJuly 16, 2026

The Top 50 Green Fleets

The List Is in: The Top 50 Green Fleets

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A car dealership with added inscription "Every fleet vehicle eventually becomes local."
Operationsby Chris BrownJuly 15, 2026

Your Local Dealer Knows More Than You Think

Your local dealer can provide an information advantage that extends well beyond courtesy deliveries.

Read More →