Automotive Fleet
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Autonomous Vehicles: Understanding Liability for Car Rental

To date, the car rental industry has been mostly left out of the picture regarding autonomous vehicles and liability. It's time to consider these issues well before autonomous vehicles are deployed.

by Mark Mackey
March 15, 2016
3 min to read


Much has already been said about liability as it pertains to autonomous vehicles (commonly referred to as self-driving or driverless cars), but car rental companies (RACs) have mostly been left out of the picture.

Some auto manufacturers (OEMs) have already stepped up and stated publicly that they should and will take responsibility for accidents caused by the autonomous vehicles that they produce.

Ad Loading...

Consumer advocates and legal scholars have advocated for this scenario, as well, since it incorporates various current elements of tort law, including product liability.

While the chain of liability is relatively simple between a plaintiff and an OEM, the waters become muddied when RACs enter the picture, which they will inevitably do. OEMs are forming partnerships with taxi and ride-sharing services around the world in order to support an imminent growth explosion in driverless taxis. RACs will likely need to embrace the technology in one form or another.

Many OEMs are developing proprietary technology to enable varying degrees of autonomy in vehicles, with the eventual goal of vehicles becoming fully autonomous. Technology companies such as Google and Apple have been at the forefront of such initiatives, although the likelihood of those companies manufacturing and selling vehicles on a large scale — versus licensing their technology and systems to some OEMs — is tenuous.

Some degree of autonomy is already present in the market, including lane-keep assist, proximity warnings, electronic stability control, and even cruise control. The path to a completely driverless vehicle will be paved with increasingly autonomous features, requiring varying degrees of driver control and awareness.

The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) has promulgated defined degrees of autonomy ranging from zero to four. For the purposes of this article, a vehicle falling within the first three categories will be designated as a semi-autonomous vehicle (SAV), or those that require some degree of manual driver control and awareness.

Ad Loading...

A category four would be designated as a fully autonomous vehicle (FAV), requiring no user input and potentially excluding steering wheels, gas, and brake pedals. SAVs pose the most pressing risks, both because they will be first to market (therefore the risks will present themselves sooner) and also because of the increased likelihood of user error.

Numerous states have either enacted laws pertaining to autonomous vehicles or have such legislation pending. While the majority of these laws merely direct applicable regulatory organizations to promulgate substantive rules, some of them contain authorizations to test autonomous vehicles and even describe criteria for the operation of SAVs or FAVs on public roads.

In the absence of laws specific to the operation of autonomous vehicles, liability for moving violations and accidents falls on the human operating the vehicle or in the driver’s seat (absent claims of defects and other liability that remove the driver from fault). The future landscape of applicable autonomous vehicle laws will hopefully be coordinated as to requirements and allocation of liability. Several model statutes have been drafted and proposed, though none specifically address RACs.

Collectively, the car rental industry should look to insert express language in future autonomous vehicle laws and carry over liability structures from generic autonomous vehicle laws to existing RAC-specific statutes.

Given potential insurance industry initiatives to create no-fault funds for accident victims, and the potential for either separate SAV operator licenses or license endorsements and even FAV occupants not needing to have a license, there will be many specific RAC requirements that should be edited accordingly.

Ad Loading...

The Graves Amendment (blocking vicarious liability of RACs for accidents caused by renters, absent negligent entrustment) may need to be updated, or it may be at risk overall.

There are many unique liability situations that will result from increasing autonomous vehicle capabilities, most of which have not yet been fully fleshed out. RACs should make sure to keep up with developments in technology and applicable laws to ensure that they can adequately account for and mitigate risks.

In the May/June issue, we’ll discuss those potential RAC-specific liability risks relating to autonomous vehicles and strategies to mitigate them.

About the Author

Mark Mackey is corporate counsel for The Hertz Corporation.

 

Originally posted on Auto Rental News

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Global Fleet

SponsoredMarch 1, 2026

One University Cut Motor Pool Costs by $45K. Here's the Playbook.

Still managing your motor pool with spreadsheets and manual approvals? Loyola University replaced outdated processes with automated fleet management, eliminating overtime and saving up to $50,000 annually. See how they did it.

Read More →
A world graphic of workers holding hands surrounds a globe with a line of cars on top, representing Global Fleets.
Global Fleetby News/Media ReleaseOctober 30, 2025

Enterprise Fleet Management Surpasses 900,000 Vehicles in U.S. & Canada

Enterprise Mobility connects with mobility solutions around the globe

Read More →
Two people pose with a sign symbolizing Viaduct's partnership with SRI.
Global Fleetby Chris BrownSeptember 8, 2025

Sumitomo Rubber Industries to Acquire Viaduct

Viaduct will join Sumitomo as an independent subsidiary. Partnership strengthens global reach and accelerates AI-driven innovation for fleets and manufacturing.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A presenter speaks on stage at a conference, addressing an audience seated at round tables, with large screens displaying presentation slides in the background.
Global FleetAugust 11, 2025

AfMA’s 2025 Education & Leadership Summit: 26 Years of Impactful Connection

Held in Sydney, the Australasian Fleet Management Association’s 2025 Summit marked ten years of growth as the event expanded its global reach and doubled down on practical, non-commercial fleet leadership programming.

Read More →
Graphic of awards announcement
Global Fleetby StaffJune 6, 2025

Closing Soon! Nominate a 2025 Global Fleet Team of the Year

Submit your nomination for the award that honors outstanding multinational fleet teams. Nominations close Aug. 15.

Read More →
A graphic with cars driving past in the background with motion blur. Text reads "Reducing Preventable Accidents".
Global FleetNovember 26, 2024

Seven Strategies to Reduce Preventable Accidents

“Accidents” suggest inevitability, but most crashes are preventable — caused by driver actions and behaviors. Here’s why shifting the narrative can improve road safety.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Four people sitting on stage doing presentation.
Global Fleetby Chris BrownNovember 6, 2024

2024 Global Fleet Conference in Photos

Check out photos from the first two days of the 2024 Global Fleet Conference, which convened for the first time in San Diego Nov. 4-6 as part of the new Fleet Week series of conferences.

Read More →
A black and blue graphic with a business portrait of Colin Sutherland, with text detailing his interview with Chris Brown.
Global Fleetby StaffOctober 17, 2024

Inside the 2024 Global Fleet Conference: Insights from Bobit CEO Colin Sutherland

With GFC joining Fleet Forward and Fleet Safety Conferences, attendees can engage in essential discussions on procurement, ESG goals, and safety.

Read More →
A sky blue and lime green graphic detailing the Global Fleet Conference seminar "Strategies to Reduce Fleet C02 Emissions on a Journey to Achieve Net-Zero."
Global Fleetby StaffOctober 11, 2024

Global Fleet Conference: Achieving Net-Zero Goals

On Nov. 5 in San Diego, join industry leaders from Schindler Elevator and Geotab as they share ideas and approaches to reaching emissions goals in global fleet operations.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A blue and gold graphic detailing open nominations for the 2024 Global Fleet Manager of the Year.
Global Fleetby StaffJuly 23, 2024

Call for Nominations: 2024 Global Fleet Manager of the Year

Nominate a fleet manager or team today and recognize some of the best and brightest in the global fleet industry.

Read More →