Automotive Fleet
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

U.S. Study Hasn't Found Toyota Electronic Defects

WASHINGTON - After five months of investigating sudden-acceleration issues involving Toyota vehicles, U.S. Transportation Department officials said they have identified no safety defects other than the ones reported by Toyota: sticky gas pedals and floor mats that can entrap gas pedals, the Wall Street Journal reported.

by Staff
August 11, 2010
3 min to read


WASHINGTON - After five months of investigating sudden-acceleration issues involving Toyota vehicles, U.S. Transportation Department officials said they have identified no safety defects other than the ones reported by Toyota: sticky gas pedals and floor mats that can entrap gas pedals, the Wall Street Journal reported. 

Speaking to members of Congress on Tuesday, Aug. 10, federal safety officials said that in more than half of the cases of sudden acceleration studied, data collected from the vehicles' "black boxes" -- or event data recorders -- indicated the driver was not applying the brake at the time of the crash. This finding suggests driver error may be at fault. 

Ad Loading...

However, officials stressed that the investigation is ongoing and may take months to finish. Thus far, though, data supports Toyota's argument that electronic defects aren't behind the incidents, the Wall Street Journal reported. 

NHTSA investigators studied 58 vehicles involved in sudden-acceleration reports. They discovered data in 35 of them that showed the brakes weren't applied at the time of the crash. 

The preliminary report doesn't specify driver error as a cause of unintended acceleration. But people familiar with the investigation have suggested that pedal misapplication -- drivers mistakenly applying the gas instead of the brake -- is a likely cause. 

In five of the 58 vehicles studied, the data recorders failed to record the conditions in the vehicle at the time of the crash. The recorders from five additional vehicles indicated that the brakes were applied early in the incident or in the middle. In one case both the brake and gas pedals were applied. In another, evidence suggested that the floor mat had likely trapped the gas pedal because braking was sustained.

Data from nine other vehicles indicated the brakes were used only in the last moment before impact. 

Ad Loading...

NHTSA restricted its review of the event data recorders to MY 2007 or later Toyota and Lexus vehicles.

These preliminary findings are likely to stir debate over the reliability of event data recorders -- an issue that has surfaced in many civil cases involving collisions. 

Toyota faces a class-action lawsuit asserting that sudden and unintended acceleration events are linked to the vehicles' electronic throttle control. In response, Toyota has issued the following statement: 

"Toyota looks forward to defending against the allegations made in the plaintiffs' consolidated complaint. Toyota has identified two specific mechanical causes of potential unintended acceleration in some of its vehicles and has moved decisively to address these issues with effective and durable solutions. Toyota rejects claims that plaintiffs suffered economic damages because of the recent recalls.

"Importantly, to date, plaintiffs have not cited a specific cause that would support their claim of a defect in Toyota's Electronic Throttle Control System, and no credible scientific theory or proof has been advanced to support this allegation. Toyota firmly believes that the system is completely safe and that reliable scientific evidence will demonstrate the safety of our vehicles in the investigations currently underway and, ultimately, to the court." 

Toyota has recalled more than 8 million vehicles globally to address the sticky gas pedal and floor mat entrapment issues.

More Safety

Chris Brown sits across from safety experft at Lifesaver mobile in an interview about distracted driving and phone use tech.
Safetyby Chris BrownMay 1, 2026

Reducing Risk by Eliminating Phone Use Behind the Wheel

Distracted driving remains one of the most persistent risks in fleet operations. New approaches focus on removing mobile device use entirely while adding real-time safety support.

Read More →
Safetyby Jeanny RoaApril 15, 2026

Distracted Driving in the Age of Smart Tech – Part 2

As distraction risks evolve, fleets are turning to smarter, more connected technologies to better understand what’s happening behind the wheel. Part 2 explores how these tools are helping identify risky behaviors and improve visibility across operations.

Read More →
Safetyby Jeanny RoaApril 11, 2026

 Data Rights, Risks, and Responsibilities After a Crash

What fleets capture to improve safety can also expose them in litigation, forcing leaders to rethink how data is managed, stored, and shared.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Driver holding a phone while steering, illustrating distracted driving and the importance of mental awareness and attention on the road for fleet safety.
Safetyby Judie NuskeyApril 10, 2026

From Distraction to Detection: Strengthening Awareness in Fleet Drivers

Distracted driving is often measured by what we can see—phones in hand, eyes off the road. But what about the distractions we can’t? A recent incident raises a bigger question about awareness, attention, and why subtle risks so often go unnoticed.

Read More →
Safetyby StaffApril 8, 2026

Lytx 2026 Road Safety Report

While serious crashes are declining, a rise in minor incidents and ongoing risk hotspots underscore the need for continued fleet safety investment.

Read More →
Driver’s hands on steering wheel in a sunlit vehicle, representing real-world driver behavior and the shift from data monitoring to hands-on training in fleet safety programs.
Safetyby Judie NuskeyApril 7, 2026

Behind-the-Wheel vs. Classroom Training: What Actually Changes Driver Behavior?

Fleets have more driver data than ever, so why isn't behavior changing? Training requires more than reports and coaching — it requires real-world practice.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
A person in a car on their phone behind the steering wheel.
Safetyby Jeanny RoaApril 1, 2026

Distracted Driving in the Age of Smart Tech – Part 1

A two-part conversation with Stefan Heck on how AI is transforming the fight against distracted driving. As fleets adopt smarter tools, the focus shifts from reacting to preventing risk. In Part 1, we look at where AI is making an impact for fleets today.

Read More →
Pedestrians crossing a busy street, highlighting the importance of driver awareness and caution to prevent pedestrian accidents.
Safetyby StaffMarch 30, 2026

Pedestrian Safety Starts With the Driver

More people on foot means more risk for drivers. These pedestrian safety tips can help prevent serious injuries and keep everyone safer on the road.

Read More →
SponsoredMarch 30, 2026

Safety by Design: Power and Protection in the Freightliner 114SD Plus

Safer crews. Fewer incidents. Better uptime. Learn how driver-assist technology is changing the way vocational fleets operate.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Safetyby StaffMarch 26, 2026

Pedestrian Deaths Drop in First Half of 2025, Marking Largest Decline in Years

An 11% drop in pedestrian fatalities in early 2025 signals progress in U.S. road safety, but elevated death rates and ongoing risks underscore the need for continued action from fleets and policymakers.

Read More →