Automotive Fleet
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Autonomous Vehicles: No Safety Without Security

The automotive industry needs a comprehensive approach to emerging automotive cybersecurity standards and regulations. Agreeing upon a cybersecurity development lifecycle is an important step.

by Michael Maass, Motional
March 1, 2022
Autonomous Vehicles: No Safety Without Security

Autonomous systems may be safe in the absence of a malicious actor, but malicious actors are not above subverting safety mechanisms to achieve their goals.

Photo courtesy of Motional

3 min to read


Autonomous vehicles that can safely operate without a driver, known as SAE Level 4 technologies, have the potential to save millions of lives by eliminating automotive accidents caused by human error. That vision of safer streets is what drives us at Motional as we tackle making these vehicles a reality.

The sophistication of Level 4 technology and its real-world applications, however, demand a safety-first ethos across every aspect of creating, testing, and, ultimately, deploying autonomous vehicles. Within this, cybersecurity plays a critical role in the overall safety of autonomous vehicles (AVs). We regularly stress this with a mantra: “There is no safety without security.” This mantra reminds us that a system may be safe in the absence of a malicious actor, but malicious actors are not above subverting safety mechanisms to achieve their goals.

Ad Loading...

At Motional, we’ve taken the unique step in making our cybersecurity approach public both to be transparent and to help advance security standards and best practices.

Autonomous Vehicle Security

At present, when we talk about autonomous vehicle security, we’re also often talking about the security of traditional vehicles and it’s worth noting that the automotive industry still has a ways to go on this front. The industry didn’t bring cybersecurity to the forefront until relatively recently. In the past several years, it has emerged as a pressing issue given the rise of software defined driver assist features and pervasive connectivity solutions. Now experts predict that the automotive cybersecurity market could reach $9.7 billion by 2030.

That figure applies to security for human-piloted vehicles — autonomous vehicles are even more cybersecurity-critical given the many layers of technology and reliance on automation for safe operation. Those of us in the autonomous industry are faced with the complex task of securing AVs, all while the automotive industry is still improving the security of human driven vehicles. There’s not a clear playbook for anyone to follow when dealing with this level of complexity.

That said, we see an important opportunity for companies in the autonomous industry to serve as leaders in establishing and following rigorous standards for cybersecurity across the automotive industry. Within the AV space, we don’t have the luxury of trial and error, we have to implement a strong security approach from the beginning in order to ensure the safety of our vehicles.

The newly released ISO/SAE 21434 standard covers the engineering aspects of vehicle security, but as it’s new, there aren’t defined norms for how to interpret and comply with the requirements. We’ve set out to change that.

Ad Loading...

Last year, we released Motional’s Autonomous Vehicle Cybersecurity Development Lifecycle (AVCDL), the first publicly released cybersecurity development lifecycle in the automotive industry and the first public effort to comprehensively comply with emerging automotive cybersecurity standards and regulations, including ISO/SAE 21434 and UNECE WP.29 R155. The AVCDL is a framework designed to enable companies to attain certifications under the aforementioned standards and regulations.

Safety Over Competition

We created the AVCDL to ensure the security of our product and then released it publicly to contribute to improving the security of the entire industry. Safety over competition has long been an important part of Motional’s overarching safety commitment. Our team pioneered safety-focused data sharing in the AV industry with the release of our nuScenes and nuPlan datasets. By releasing these datasets, our goal was to further the research that would make all AVs smarter and safer — not just our own. The AVCDL follows nuScenes legacy by sharing the lifecycle with the broader community.

We’ve  invited our partners, suppliers, and others in the industry to provide feedback, with the intention of making everyone’s security practices stronger. The cybersecurity landscape is constantly changing. Thus, we view cybersecurity as a journey, where cross-industry collaboration will help us continue to stay ahead of the threat. We hope others will join us on this journey.

About the Author: Michael Maass, Ph.D., is the cybersecurity lead and principal engineer at Motional, an autonomous driving joint venture formed by Aptiv and Hyundai Motor Group with operations across the U.S. and in Asia. The company is developing and commercializing Level 4 robotaxis. Motional has partnerships with Lyft, Via, and Uber Eats to deploy its robotaxis on their networks. Read more at mindsofmotional.medium.com

This article was authored and edited according to Fleet Forward editorial standards and style. Opinions expressed may not necessarily reflect that of Fleet Forward.

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Fleet Forward

seminar card for Gray Fleet Risk session at Fleet Forward Conference
Fleet Forwardby StaffJuly 24, 2026

Is Your Grey Fleet Creating an Unmanaged Safety Risk?

NCR Atleos Fleet Manager Jose Rocha will join Cardata and SambaSafety experts at Fleet Forward Conference to examine how fleets can extend safety oversight to every employee who drives for business.

Read More →
speaker image for Fleet Forward Conference session on agentic AI
Fleet Forwardby StaffJuly 22, 2026

Agentic AI Session at FFC Will Help Fleets Turn Data Into TCO Action

Mike Albert Fleet Solutions and Motorq will show how agentic AI can uncover maintenance, fuel, and utilization savings buried across disconnected fleet data.

Read More →
Graphic featuring the seven 2026 Fleet Hall of Fame nominees: Elsie Lucia, John Dmochowsky, Lee Miller, Frank Memolo, Roger Peterson, Mark F. Petersen, and Dave Durepo.
Fleet Forwardby Faith HowellJuly 21, 2026

Voting Opens for 2026 Fleet Hall of Fame

See the nominations for the 2026 Hall of Fame and select your choice for this year's class!

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Cover of the "Top 50 Green Fleets" report presented by Automotive Fleet and Inspiration Fleet, featuring an aerial nighttime photo of a lit highway interchange with looping ramps.
SponsoredJuly 16, 2026

The Top 50 Green Fleets

The List Is in: The Top 50 Green Fleets

Read More →
visionary finalists
Fleet Forwardby Faith HowellJuly 16, 2026

7 Fleet Professionals Named Finalists for the 2026 Fleet Visionary Award

Meet the 2026 nominees for the Fleet Visionary Award.

Read More →
a graphic of the 9 finalists for the 2026 fleet manager of the year
Fleet Forwardby Faith HowellJuly 15, 2026

9 Fleet Leaders Nominated for the 2026 Fleet Manager of the Year Award

Meet the nine finalists for the 2026 Fleet Manager of the Year Award.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
title card for the 2026 Fleet Forward Conference
Fleet Forwardby StaffJuly 13, 2026

Fleet Forward Conference to Debut First Registration-Based Analysis of Largest Commercial Fleets

The session will deliver an exclusive first look at registration data covering more than 1.5 million commercial vehicles, offering one of the industry's most detailed views of the private fleet market.

Read More →
Collage of Fleet Forward Conference photos and Registration Open wording
Fleet Forwardby StaffJuly 7, 2026

Registration Opens for 2026 Fleet Forward Conference

Held on the East Coast for the first time, the Washington, D.C.-area event features expert-led education, a new IIHS Crash Test Experience, and collocation with the NAFA’s Fleet Safety Symposium.

Read More →
Composite graphic featuring portraits of NAFA’s 2026 Fellows: Clyde “Dale” Collins, Patti Earley, Bryan Flansburg, Bob Mossing and Cedric Roberts, recognized for fleet leadership and service.
Fleet Forwardby News/Media ReleaseJune 11, 2026

Earley, Mossing Named to NAFA's 2026 Class of Fellows

The honor recognizes five outstanding professionals whose leadership, service and contributions have made a significant impact on NAFA and the fleet management profession.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
Attendees watch a live vehicle crash test at the IIHS Vehicle Research Center, where fleet professionals can observe safety testing and advanced crash-avoidance technologies in action.
Fleet ForwardJune 4, 2026

Fleet Forward Conference Adds IIHS Crash Test Experience for 2026 Attendees

Attendees will witness a live crash test, tour the IIHS Vehicle Research Center, and experience advanced crash-avoidance technologies firsthand.

Read More →