The Car and Truck Fleet and Leasing Management Magazine

Fleet vs Retail! Is There an Edge, or Not?

September 2004, by Ed Bobit - Also by this author

 We are not created equal, and our differences are often greater than our similarities.-Carlton Fredericks

We will have equality when a female schlemiel moves ahead as fast as a male schlemiel.-Estelle Ramey

Before God and the bus driver we are all equal.-German Proverb

After death all men smell alike.-Italian Proverb


I've suddenly got a whole new hero! My heroes usually fit a certain mold; and now even that is over. Hey, maybe not all of you know about John Wayne, a local boy who made it good. All of us who met him called him "Duke." He didn't take crap from anybody.

Then Bruce Willis, an unlikely sort with an unlikely first name, got me snagged with his Die Hard series just like Mel Gibson reeled me in with his Lethal Weapon series. All macho and smart.

My new replacement hero is hardly who you or I might have expected. You've never heard of him and I didn't either before the end of July when the Wall Street Journal (of all people) ran a story about him.

Michael McGovern is his name; he's a 23-year-old from Foothill Ranch here in California. It's just across the mountain range and the valley from where I plod. He's not a movie star or a fleet manager. He's some average "Joe Consumer" who works as a waiter (and probably writes hopeful screenplays in off hours, like everyone else around here seems to).

Now all of us know that fleet managers are the professionals when it comes to buying cars and trucks. They buy a lot of them so they know how to negotiate and bargain well beyond what any consumer-type might hope to do. It's the classic "Fleet vs. Retail" image that often happens even within factory personnel.

Consumers are emotional with their purchases. Some are soccer moms who don't seem to have any problem climbing up on a running board rail and with yet another step can actually get into the cab of that SUV or truck with 17-inch wheels. They adore that "power view."

Hey, the experienced fleet manager isn't like that. He or she doesn't even want to hear about a turboed V-8 or V-12. No, they're looking for that less than spectacular mid-size car; or some van with hardly any windows, or rear doors that open sideways for the ladders on top with a 4- or 6-banger. How deliciously sexy is that?

All that doesn't matter though because every fleet manager worth his/her salt will tell you that they know how to buy, how to negotiate, how to wring every last factory dollar out of the seller and be so damned proud of the tiers set up for CAP incentives that they'd slake their job on it.

That's not all of it they're proud to say. When you consider early order incentives, getting a guarantee purchase price for every vehicle ordered all year, noshing with the dealer at invoice, and whittling away at his holdback, well no one can do more. Right?

Maybe, "wrong!!" My new hero just may have pulled it off. He actually purchased a loaded midsize domestic SUV with no leverage at all. He was able to systematically pile factory and dealer rebates on top of one another until he had an astounding $8,500 worth of 'em (I also wanted to find out if he qualified and received the 0-percent financing; the Journal didn't report on it).

I've been trying to find any of my fleet manager friends who can tell me that their factory deal is better than what my hero got. No one can believe what McGovern was able to do on a single, non-professional purchase. Of course they (the fleet mangers) all say that "we can always take advantage of tiny retail incentives like consumers if we see they're better."

My impression is that even the most affluent fleet managers don't monitor regional consumer incentives, so in many eases they simply wouldn't know about a McGovern deal. I also have a concern about those who signed a three-year single source deal without a floating incentive clause. Ouch!!

So there actually is some "equality" between fleet and retail from time to time. Kind of gets you back to the old saying, "let the buyer beware." Maybe the only way to keep the edge on for fleet managers is to have the factories guarantee the residuals (wink, wink).



Twitter Facebook Google+


Please note that comments may be moderated. 
Leave this field empty:

Fleet Incentives

Determine the actual cost of owning and running a vehicle in your fleet. Compare vehicles by class and model.


Fleet Tracking And Telematics

Todd Ewing from Verizon Connect will answer your questions and challenges

View All


Fleet Management And Leasing

Jack Firriolo from Merchants will answer your questions and challenges

View All


Fuel Management

Bernie Kanavagh from WEX will answer your questions and challenges

View All


Sponsored by

The California ARB oversees all air pollution control efforts in California to attain and maintain health-based air quality standards.

Read more


Market Trends

Mike Antich
Upward Pressure on Fleet Costs Threatens to Increase TCO

By Mike Antich
Recently, I conducted a survey of several hundred fleet managers to identify emerging industry trends. One recurrent theme expressed by fleet managers was the concern that fleet costs are starting to experience upward pricing pressures. Here's what they told me.

How to Minimize Unauthorized Use of Corporate Assets

By Mike Antich

View All

Driving Notes

Mike Antich
2018 Chevrolet Equinox Diesel

By Mike Antich
The Chevrolet Equinox adds a 1.6L four-cylinder turbo diesel to its lineup of engine choices for 2018. The fuel-efficient turbo diesel generates 137 hp and 240 lb.-ft. of torque mated to a six-speed automatic.

2018 Volkswagen Tiguan

By Paul Clinton

View All

Nobody Asked Me, But...

Sherb Brown
Adapting to a Changing Tide

By Sherb Brown
Fleets are often the beta testers of the vehicle market. That shift away from compact sedans we saw in the fleet market a few years ago is playing out in real time in the retail market right now.

Keep Realistic Fleet Expectations

By Sherb Brown

View All

Data Points

Dylan Brown
What Are the Most Valuable Services Offered by FMCs?

By Dylan Brown
What do fleet managers value in their relationships with fleet management companies? The answer may surprise you.

Demand More From Your Fuel Card Provider

By Dylan Brown

View All

In Memoriam: Coach's Insights

Ed Bobit
Thinking of the Newbies of the Future

By Ed Bobit
A lot has changed in the past 10-15 years, so we can only imagine this momentum will continue into the next decade-plus. How will this change impact the fleet manager of tomorrow?

Managing a Car vs. Work Truck Fleet

By Ed Bobit

View All


Up Next

More From The World's Largest Fleet Publisher