Automotive Fleet
MenuMENU
SearchSEARCH

Who Has a True Appreciation for Depreciation?

No one would suggest we ignore the current egregious fuel prices. However, to mimic my personal mantra for the last 50 years, resale values continue to identify the vehicle’s most costly item.

Ed Bobit
Ed BobitFormer Editor & Publisher
July 6, 2011
3 min to read


If you read the media regularly or attend the manufacturers’ future product previews, each and every one of them is touting the significant used-car value increases over the last few years.

Little mention is made that 2009 was a disastrous new-car sales year with fewer retail buyers because the nation was deep into a recession. Many fleets also found they could extend recycling and thereby reduce new purchases. In fact, it was so bad that some of the OEMs were forced into a financial reorganization.

Ad Loading...

It also prompted the OEMs to drastically reduce “program car” policies (convenient buy-back arrangements), which virtually dried up the daily rental market’s major contribution to the auction market. 

All this “action” formed a sort of tsunami in remarketing. For months now, used-vehicle values have exploded because the demand for good used cars is very strong and the availability of product is heavily reduced — so much so that auctions are consolidating locations, and some are actually closing.

Tom Webb, Manheim’s economic guru says, “The trough in new vehicles sales is still about three years away. We can expect the lack of whole supply will continue, which will continue to bolster resale prices…”

ADESA’s guru, Tom Kontos says, in part, “Average wholesale prices remain at near-record levels as concerns about new-vehicle supply disruptions and high gas prices add to the tight-supply/high-demand dynamic; new-vehicle incentives are down considerably, giving more upside support.”

Fortunately, fuel prices are coming down so the hot used-car market commands more focus than ever for the fleet manager. So, if you’ve been to the recent factory fleet previews, each OEM proudly displays charts showing the dramatic increase in resale values for its vehicles. Everybody is a winner right now; especially in the lower-cost, fuel-efficient models.

Ad Loading...

In the mix are the OEM price increases. At least one major fleet supplier has announced three price adjustments since January of this year, adding an average $375 to the sticker. And, special fleet incentives are getting tighter with good retail demand and lower dealer inventories. More evidence is confirmed as you see “nothing short of amazing” retail lease promotions. One import brand is actually “guaranteeing” an ALG used-car value as you buy now for your trade-in 24-36 months from purchase, thus buying the same brand.

Incredibly, most of the fleet managers I discuss responsibilities with assure me they know how to negotiate and buy, but are quite happy to outsource the major remarketing function. Now is the most critical time, perhaps in history, when their professional knowledge is required to save their company huge dollars and visibly demonstrate how valuable their talents are.

The obvious answer is partial short cycling, who know both the buying and the remarketing (plus have the ear of management). Among the elite who are executing this model or are strongly studying it for short-term action are Jim McCarthy from Siemens, Michael Beiger from ADP (both attendees of our Conference of Automotive Remarketing [CAR]), David Haselrud of 3M, Don Schaefer of USG, Mike Sims from LDS Church, and others who are proven leaders.

What’s not to like about short cycling? You’re undoubtedly trading a less-efficient mpg unit for a better one. You can probably cover both with the OEM warranty usage. You lower your maintenance and driver downtime. And, you take advantage of the hottest resale market you’ve probably ever witnessed and make more of your drivers very happy. Plus, you’re a hero!

My question is, “How can you not do it?”

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

More Blog Posts

Thinking of the Newbies of the Future

A lot has changed in the past 10-15 years, so we can only imagine this momentum will continue into the next decade-plus. How will this change impact the fleet manager of tomorrow?

Read More →
In Memoriam: Coach's Insightsby Ed BobitJune 13, 2014

Managing a Car vs. Work Truck Fleet

Work truck fleets run fewer miles than the typical car fleet, but companies hold these vehicles longer until they get into the costly area of maintenance, including preventive maintenance intervals. Every part of a work truck is driven harder.

Read More →
In Memoriam: Coach's Insightsby Ed BobitMay 20, 2014

So, What's New?

Even though I have been critical (constructively so, I hope) in past years, after a good deal of thought, it occurs to me that NAFA needs strong continued support from the entire industry.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
In Memoriam: Coach's Insightsby Ed BobitApril 22, 2014

Sometimes, a Mystery is Nothing More than an Enigma

In late February, virtually every member of the NAFA office staff received a new or additional assignment and a new title to go with it. All to meet the goals of their "very aggressive strategic plans" (no specifics identified).

Read More →
In Memoriam: Coach's Insightsby Ed BobitMarch 20, 2014

The Shortest Distance from Point 'A' to Point 'B'

This year, the Fleet Safety Conference will demonstrate the latest developments in technology and the use of predictive analytics and other metrics to identify at-risk drivers.

Read More →
In Memoriam: Coach's Insightsby Ed BobitFebruary 21, 2014

Be Careful What You Wish For!

Despite the compact truck market diving from 2 million sales to 250,000, there appears to be ample competition coming. Most believe the compact truck market is now expanding and will continue.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
In Memoriam: Coach's Insightsby Ed BobitJanuary 9, 2014

Fuel or Resale: Where Can You Find the Biggest Savings Now?

With mpg improving with each new model and prices at the pump receding, some are forgetting the more expensive depreciation cost.

Read More →
In Memoriam: Coach's Insightsby Ed BobitDecember 16, 2013

Set Your Priorities for Another Challenging Year

Make sure that you not only learn about resale values, but you should be getting a free (customary for dealers and fleets) lunch at your favorite auction. Maybe your FMC is taking it for you.

Read More →

The 12 NEW Complaints of Christmas

Thinking of the 12 Days of Christmas song, I thought I would substitute 12 hopefully smile-generating complaints that I’ve heard customers say. You’re lucky I decided not share this as a video since I’m banned from most karaoke clubs… Perhaps you and your staff have heard some of these comments/responses.

Read More →
Ad Loading...
In Memoriam: Coach's Insightsby Ed BobitNovember 8, 2013

7 Ways We Can Achieve Recognition of the Values of the Fleet Function

From my own experience, nothing gets an exec's attention more than a testimonial on a potential money-saving idea. And, why not make the benefit come back to the fleet manager?

Read More →