Traditional tire designs will need to change to accommodate the impact of electric drivetrains....

Traditional tire designs will need to change to accommodate the impact of electric drivetrains. Increased vehicle weights and higher bi-directional torque loads will force tire makers to rethink tire design and construction with a focus on reducing rolling resistance.

Photo: Jim Park

The operating characteristics of electric drivetrains, coupled with heavy battery loads, will change the way tires for electric trucks are built. In addition to providing good traction, low rolling resistance and long miles to removal, drive tires for battery-electric trucks will need to withstand higher torque loads, while steer tires will be subject to higher vertical loads than traditional tires.

Those operational factors will apply not only to heavy-duty Class 8 trucks, but also to lighter Class 5 and 6 delivery vehicles. The tare weights of the vehicles will increase, probably compromising payloads slightly. It will also tighten the margin on load carry capacity for some tires, particularly steer tires (see sidebar at the end of the story).

Torque loads on drive tires will increase not only thanks to the higher output of electric motors compared to internal combustion engines, but also because regenerative braking will impart torsional forces on tires in the opposite direction. This will affect tire tread wear as well as sidewalls. And it will be more of a consideration in high stop-and-go applications — the exact type of local delivery operations that many see as one of the best applications for electric vehicles.

“Higher torque on the drive axle will result in higher wear rate,” says Hinnerk Kaiser, Continental’s head of product development. “In addition, a higher share of braking torque can increase the risk of irregular wear phenomena — heel and toe wear. Both criteria are key performance factors for drive tire development anyway, but we have to set a higher focus for electric trucks. This can lead to an adapted pattern and contour layout, such as groove design, void distribution, tread pattern depths, etc.”

We may also have to rethink directionality in drive tires. Aside from being logistically annoying (getting the right tire going in the right direction during installation), such tires were designed to handle torque from only one direction.

“When they design directional tires, they don’t look at brake torques,” says Mahesh Kavaturu, Goodyear’s commercial technology director. “It’s not a constant feature, but regenerative braking will produce more sustained brake torques.”

Minimize Wear, Improve Performance

While truck makers and driveline engineers will come up with ways of managing or mitigating torque at launch, the additional brake torque due to constant regenerative braking will put additional energy to the tire, manifesting itself as tread wear.

“That’s where we really have to innovate,” says Goodyear’s Kavaturu. “We are focused on bringing new reinforcement materials like silica [and] carbon black, as well as new steel reinforcements to our tires, to ensure that in the face of all those additional demands, we can maintain tread wear to the degree experienced by ICE vehicles.”

While fleets operating electric vehicles may tolerate shorter tread life or higher degrees of irregular wear during the development phase, they will expect those issues to be sorted out in the near term. But fleets and truck makers will also be looking for even lower rolling resistance to prolong battery life.

“While rolling resistance is a factor for diesel-powered vehicles for fuel efficiency, for electric trucks it relates to the range of miles the vehicle can travel before it needs to be recharged,” explains Mike Steiner, Michelin field engineer. “Rolling resistance may take on an even higher level of importance in order to meet the range needs of the fleets operating the electric trucks.”

Continental presented this hand-made prototype tire for electric trucks at the Frankfurt Motor...

Continental presented this hand-made prototype tire for electric trucks at the Frankfurt Motor Show in 2018. In line with the “tall-and-narrow” concept, wherever practical, tires with a large diameter can help to keep rolling resistance down.

Photo: Continental

The quest for lower rolling resistance could take us into hitherto unknown territory. In testing at its research and development facilities in Europe, Continental has been experimenting with “tall and narrow” tires to reduce rolling resistance. A hand-built prototype 205/65R22 tire has already proven successful in improving rolling resistance, but the size is not something we’re likely to adopt readily here in North America.

“That particular size was chosen based on preferences from [European truck maker] MAN for their concept electric vehicle,” a Continental spokesperson told HDT. “So far, OEMs have not indicated that this tire size will be used on serial production vehicles. However, we do anticipate that tall and narrow tires will become more popular on electric trucks. Tires with a large diameter can help keep rolling resistance down on account of their size alone, amplifying the effects of tread compounding and other initiatives.”

Repositioning and retreading

While we are still in early days of development of tires for electric trucks, there’s no need to begin fretting about repositioning those tires to trailer positions or even about retreadability. They will both obviously be design considerations. Goodyear’s Kavaturu indicated that maintaining traditional tire sizing is of paramount importance.

That said, if, as Goodyear suggests, steer tires migrate out from 11-inch tread widths to 12 or 12.5 inches, there will be mixing concerns, which might limit repositioning and ultimately the value in retreading such tires. The same goes for tall and narrow tires, should they find their way into service here.

Today we enjoy all-position exchangeability, where any tire can be repurposed, repositioned and retreaded. If we wind up with short, fat steer tires and tall, narrow drive tires, one wonders what will become of the traditional feedstock for trailer tires. But it’s probably a bit too early to worry about that.

Bracing for Heavier Steer Tire Loads

We know batteries will add to the tare weight of a truck. What’s not certain yet is how that weight will be distributed. From a load and inflation perspective, there’s lots of headroom with drive tires, but hardly at all with steer tires.

Inflated to 100 psi, most common drive tires for Class 8 trucks can accommodate around 5,600 pounds of load. Given that a legally loaded drive tire maxes out at 4,250 pounds, weight isn’t an issue.

But many trucks are now running 13,200- to 14,000-pound steer axles with load range H tires inflated to 120 psi — and they are maxed out. So, if truck makers put much of the battery load up front, tire makers may have to upsize their steer tires to handle the additional load.

That could mean switching from a 22.5- to a 24-inch tire or increasing the width of the tread face to 12 or 12.5 inches (300-315 mm), up from the current 11 or 11.5 inches (275-295 mm). In either case, the larger casing would accommodate a larger volume of air, which is what actually supports the load.

Fleets and truck makers, however, might be reluctant to accept a radical change in tire size. A 24-inch wheel would be a non-standard size, which would create inventory issues. Going to a taller tire might upset the carefully designed tire clearance specs for hoods and suspensions.

A likely alternative would be a wider tire.

“Upsizing the tire width gives you the extra carrying capacity while keeping the rim diameter at 22.5 inches,” says Ma-hesh Kavaturu, Goodyear’s commercial technology director. “That’s what is happening already with transit buses. They’re going from 305 to 315 mm tires. And we are also reinforcing the construction to take on additional loads beyond where even the 315 is today.”

Most motor coaches and charter buses now run 315 mm steer tires at about 130 psi. That could be what we’ll see on Class 8 BEVs in the near future.

Goodyear expects to see a similar trend on steer tires for lighter vehicles, too, the Class 5 and 6 delivery vans. The chassis packaging is evolving, says Kavaturu.

“In some cases, the batteries go up front, which will put more loads on the on the steer tires. So, with respect to upsizing, we may see tires evolve from 16- and 17.5-inch to 19-inch. That would depend on the OEM.”

Originally posted on Trucking Info

About the author
Jim Park

Jim Park

Equipment Editor

A truck driver and owner-operator for 20 years before becoming a trucking journalist, Jim Park maintains his commercial driver’s license and brings a real-world perspective to Test Drives, as well as to features about equipment spec’ing and trends, maintenance and drivers. His On the Spot videos bring a new dimension to his trucking reporting. And he's the primary host of the HDT Talks Trucking videocast/podcast.

View Bio