The Car and Truck Fleet and Leasing Management Magazine

Technology Increases Accident Management Costs in 2010

In-vehicle technology is increasing — from collision avoidance systems to additional air bags — all of which is impacting the cost of accident management.

August 2011, by Lauren Fletcher - Also by this author

To see Automotive Fleet's 2013 Accident Management Survey article, click here.

At a Glance

A marginal increase in accident costs was seen in 2010 due to such factors as: 

  • Increased in-vehicle technology
  • Use of new, waterborne paint technologies
  • Exotic metals
  • Vehicles kept in service for longer periods of time
  • Increased parts prices


In-vehicle technology is increasing — from collision avoidance systems to additional air bags — all of which is impacting the cost of accident management.

Accident management costs stayed flat, or increased marginally in 2010 over previous years. Automotive Fleet spoke with several industry experts to gauge accident management costs, trends, and what actions fleet managers can take to reduce this expense.

“We have seen a marginal increase in our average repair ticket over the last year. Cost increases have been a result of safety enhancements and computer technologies in the vehicle,” said Stuart Braun, adjuster and maintenance supervisor for Fleet Response. “More vehicles are equipped with collision avoidance systems and supplemental restraint systems, with up to six air bags per vehicle. These items paired with waterborne paint technologies and exotic metals have led to the increase in repair costs for our clients.”

Complicating matters is the fact that fleets are still in the same cost-control mode they’ve been in for the last several years.

“Depending on the age of the vehicle, as much as possible, fleets continue to avoid repairs they deem to be cosmetic. It’s not surprising that they’re more likely to repair cosmetic damage on a newer, low-mileage vehicle than an older or higher-mileage vehicle,” said John Wolford, senior manager, provider & network services for CEI.

PHH Arval is witnessing a larger number of accidents in light-duty trucks and upfitted vehicles, which has driven average costs upward.

“However, this has been offset by clients keeping vehicles longer, affording greater opportunity to utilize alternative or used parts,” said Eliot Bensel, director, vehicle accident services, PHH Arval.
Based on Fleet Response’s experience, “the downturn in the national economy has not directly affected accident management costs,” said Braun. “However, we have seen certain segments of our client base reporting fewer accidents as they have fewer vehicles on the road from previous years.”

Fleet Response continues to see clients repair only safety-related repairs, while foregoing cosmetic repairs on service and sales vehicles alike.

“The cost of accidents continues to rise because parts prices continue to increase, and there is a greater use of parts that can’t be repaired and must be replaced in the design of today’s vehicles, which is a more expensive alternative. Computers in cars and plastic parts are examples of the kind of parts that usually must be replaced instead of repaired. We’re seeing more plastic under the hood, things like cooling assemblies, fan assemblies, engine intakes, radiator supports and tanks, and even valve covers,” said Wolford of CEI.

According to Greg Neuman, quality control supervisor, senior staff appraiser, provider & network services for CEI, “We used to see parts price increases from the OEMs about once a year. Now they can occur at any and all times of the year. However, many of the increases have not been significant. It looks like competition with aftermarket parts makers has helped hold down price increases from original equipment manufacturers (OEMs). On the other hand, wherever possible, OEMs are now branding parts. For example they’re including the vehicle make name as part of the bumper. In one case, an aftermarket bumper had cost $300, but the OEM bumper with the model name molded into it was priced at $600,” he said.

Reviewing Accident Management Trends

Downsizing and right-sizing are two common trends fleets are using in reaction to the current high cost of fuel. However, these practices are having unintended results.

“In some cases, downsizing due to the economy has caused companies to take a look at more outsourcing of their fleet operations,” said Bensel of PHH Arval. “This is especially true of the communications industry, which, in many cases is growing more rapidly than infrastructures can support and outsourcing becomes a very viable alternative.”

A current trend Fleet Response noted is the rise in salvage vehicle prices.

“As a result, the price for LKQ (like kind & quality) or used parts is increasing, making them sometimes cost prohibitive to use,” said Braun. “In the past, a lot of fleets opted to use alternative parts or started reconsidering using them. Now, with the rising cost of the parts, it is taking that consideration out of the mix.”

In general, according to PHH Arval, fleets are continually working to strike the right balance between a safe and economical repair.

Additional trends are related to cost avoidance. “One difference we saw last year was that the repair cost avoidance choice was much more widespread than in 2009, with many more fleets making that choice,” said Wolford of CEI. “Fleets continue to rely on other cost-saving approaches, including using aftermarket and used parts and paintless dent repair (PDR) whenever possible.”

However, a slight increase in the percentage of claims in which the vehicle is repaired has occurred, as fleets have reached the end of the vehicle surplus that was built up following layoffs.

“During 2009, we found fleets were swapping good-condition surplus vehicles for accident-damaged vehicles and, now that the surplus inventory has been used up, fleets are now repairing more vehicles,” said Wolford of CEI.

Moving forward, a decrease in accident management costs could be on the horizon.

“We anticipate a slight decrease in accident management costs. In addition, we are seeing more availability of pool or unused units that impacted replacement vehicle or rental costs,” said Bensel of PHH Arval.

Twitter Facebook Google+


Please note that comments may be moderated. 
Leave this field empty:

Fleet Incentives

Determine the actual cost of owning and running a vehicle in your fleet. Compare vehicles by class and model.

Sponsored by

Annual award from Fleet Financials Magazine to a fleet executive who exhibit excellence and innovation in cost-saving initiatives, policy setting, innovative programs, and cultivation of fleet manager training and management


Read more

Accident Costs Calculator

Use this calculator to see how much extra sales revenue your company needs to generate to make up for the profits lost as a result of fleet accidents.
Launch Accident Cost Calculator 

Up Next

More From The World's Largest Fleet Publisher